docs(handoff): record scoped S01 approval and passing qualification

This commit is contained in:
cesnimda
2026-10-30 08:27:40 +01:00
parent 1a47f7ac1d
commit 214dbd6c4d
24 changed files with 125 additions and 42 deletions
@@ -48,16 +48,18 @@
"windows-template-oracle", "windows-template-oracle",
"linux-template-oracle" "linux-template-oracle"
], ],
"limits": "Actual revised accent clipping fixed with2mm name inset and finite native controls. S01 compares unequal metrics: original28Windows/20Linux failures retained pending owner disposition; human/print pending." "limits": "Automated accent clipping and owner-dispositioned S01 pass; human typography/spacing/printing review remains pending, so PARTIAL."
}, },
{ {
"criterion": "Automated PDF Fidelity", "criterion": "Automated PDF Fidelity",
"status": "FAIL", "status": "PASS",
"evidence": [ "evidence": [
"s01-approved-qualification",
"S01_METRIC_APPROVAL.json",
"windows-template-oracle", "windows-template-oracle",
"linux-template-oracle" "linux-template-oracle"
], ],
"limits": "Original24CV+4letter per platform pass; revised corpus fails only S01. No oracle waiver." "limits": "Finite original corpus and revised36/platform pass under explicitly owner-approved S01 vertical baseline metric, same2mm. Raw original28/20 failures retained, not relabelled. No human/printing/entry approval."
}, },
{ {
"criterion": "Semantic Content Completeness", "criterion": "Semantic Content Completeness",
@@ -135,7 +137,7 @@
"BLOCKERS.json", "BLOCKERS.json",
"READY_TO_RUN.md" "READY_TO_RUN.md"
], ],
"limits": "Missing protected entry/candidate decisions, affected PDF disposition and controller runtime/test-adapter/policy qualification." "limits": "Protected entry/candidate decisions and actual controller runtime/test-adapter/policy qualification remain pending. S01 metric-only disposition is complete; human PDF spacing remains PARTIAL."
}, },
{ {
"criterion": "Automation Handoff Package", "criterion": "Automation Handoff Package",
@@ -167,7 +169,6 @@
"P10-CANDIDATE-01", "P10-CANDIDATE-01",
"AUTO-RUNTIME-01", "AUTO-RUNTIME-01",
"AUTO-ADAPTER-01", "AUTO-ADAPTER-01",
"PDF-S01-01",
"HUMAN-01", "HUMAN-01",
"AI-CV-01", "AI-CV-01",
"DET-RECALL-01", "DET-RECALL-01",
@@ -79,17 +79,20 @@
}, },
{ {
"id": "PDF-S01-01", "id": "PDF-S01-01",
"description": "All48 revised S01 failures are explained by unequal DOM Range versus PDF character-cell metrics. They remain failed/undispositioned. A separate actual accent-clipping defect is corrected at154a9e8; finite native proofs do not approve a replacement gate or human typography.", "description": "Owner explicitly approved revised S01 vertical baseline metric at the same2mm limit for candidateba04d817 on30October2026. Both36-document platforms pass with all other checks retained; original28/20 failures remain historical raw evidence.",
"evidence": [ "evidence": [
"docs/pre-phase10-ux/ACCEPTANCE.md", "docs/pre-phase10-ux/ACCEPTANCE.md",
"VISUAL_REVIEW.md", "VISUAL_REVIEW.md",
"docs/p10-entry-final/REPORT.md", "docs/p10-entry-final/REPORT.md",
"docs/p10-entry-final/S01_CLASSIFICATION.json", "docs/p10-entry-final/S01_CLASSIFICATION.json",
"ENTRY_PROPOSAL.json" "ENTRY_PROPOSAL.json",
"S01_METRIC_APPROVAL.json",
"S01_APPROVAL.md",
"s01-approved-qualification"
], ],
"severity": "MODERATE", "severity": "MODERATE",
"acceptanceCriterion": "Required preview/PDF fidelity and visual spacing qualification", "acceptanceCriterion": "Required preview/PDF fidelity and visual spacing qualification",
"requiredAction": "Owner must inspect actual before/after PDFs and explicitly decide the proposed same2mm baseline-to-baseline revised S01 metric while retaining historical results and all font/content/page/color checks. Otherwise keep original failure. Obtain applicable protected criterion/scope disposition; no worker-written waiver or automatic entry.", "requiredAction": "Metric-only disposition complete. Human visual/print acceptance and independent protected entry/scope/runtime decisions remain pending; do not infer any other approval.",
"blockingPhase": [ "blockingPhase": [
"PHASE-10: document/rendering scope or required PDF gate", "PHASE-10: document/rendering scope or required PDF gate",
"PRODUCTION" "PRODUCTION"
@@ -97,7 +100,7 @@
"responsibleParty": "Document QA owner / owner acceptance authority", "responsibleParty": "Document QA owner / owner acceptance authority",
"deferralAuthority": null, "deferralAuthority": null,
"classification": "MANDATORY_ENTRY", "classification": "MANDATORY_ENTRY",
"status": "BLOCKED" "status": "CLOSED"
}, },
{ {
"id": "HUMAN-01", "id": "HUMAN-01",
@@ -21,8 +21,8 @@
"originalCorpus": "PASS", "originalCorpus": "PASS",
"actualAccentClippingFix": "PASS_AUTOMATED_FINITE_CORPUS", "actualAccentClippingFix": "PASS_AUTOMATED_FINITE_CORPUS",
"unchangedRevisedOracle": "FAIL", "unchangedRevisedOracle": "FAIL",
"proposedBaselineDiagnostic": "PASS_DIAGNOSTIC_ONLY_NOT_GATE_REPLACEMENT", "proposedBaselineDiagnostic": "PASS_OWNER_APPROVED_S01_Y_METRIC",
"metricDisposition": "OWNER_DECISION_REQUIRED", "metricDisposition": "OWNER_APPROVED_S01_METRIC_ONLY",
"humanVisual": "NOT_TESTED", "humanVisual": "NOT_TESTED",
"actualPrinting": "NOT_TESTED" "actualPrinting": "NOT_TESTED"
}, },
@@ -31,7 +31,6 @@
"P10-CANDIDATE-01", "P10-CANDIDATE-01",
"AUTO-RUNTIME-01", "AUTO-RUNTIME-01",
"AUTO-ADAPTER-01", "AUTO-ADAPTER-01",
"PDF-S01-01",
"HUMAN-01", "HUMAN-01",
"AI-CV-01", "AI-CV-01",
"DET-RECALL-01", "DET-RECALL-01",
@@ -77,12 +76,6 @@
} }
], ],
"requiredDecisions": [ "requiredDecisions": [
{
"id": "pdf-s01-reference-disposition",
"action": "Inspect actual native before/after samples and explicitly approve or reject same2mm baseline-to-baseline revised S01; retain original failures and independent checks.",
"state": "PENDING",
"authority": "EXPLICIT_OWNER_REFERENCE_DISPOSITION"
},
{ {
"id": "phase10-development-entry", "id": "phase10-development-entry",
"action": "Approve resolved clean published envelope/candidate and applicable mandatory evidence through existing protected entry process.", "action": "Approve resolved clean published envelope/candidate and applicable mandatory evidence through existing protected entry process.",
@@ -1,3 +1,5 @@
> **30 October 2026 — metric-only owner approval recorded.** See [S01_APPROVAL.md](S01_APPROVAL.md). Revised S01 now passes36/36 per platform under the approved same2mm vertical baseline metric; original28/20 failures remain unchanged. Human PDF spacing remains PARTIAL; Phase10 and production NO-GO. This supersedes only the metric-pending statements below.
> **P10-ENTRY-FINAL addendum — 30 October 2026 (Europe/Paris).** The revised-name clipping correction is application commit154a9e8; the current source-bound candidate is in ACCEPTANCE.json/ENTRY_PROPOSAL.json. Read [the complete current report](../../../p10-entry-final/REPORT.md), [native PDF guide](../../../p10-entry-final/REVIEW_GUIDE.md) and [owner actions](../../../p10-entry-final/OWNER_REVIEW.md). Original S01 failures28Windows/20Linux remain FAIL pending explicit metric disposition; actual accent clipping is fixed on the finite corpus. Phase10 and production NO-GO; automatic execution false. No deletion scope, protected approval, model qualification or controller activation is supplied. > **P10-ENTRY-FINAL addendum — 30 October 2026 (Europe/Paris).** The revised-name clipping correction is application commit154a9e8; the current source-bound candidate is in ACCEPTANCE.json/ENTRY_PROPOSAL.json. Read [the complete current report](../../../p10-entry-final/REPORT.md), [native PDF guide](../../../p10-entry-final/REVIEW_GUIDE.md) and [owner actions](../../../p10-entry-final/OWNER_REVIEW.md). Original S01 failures28Windows/20Linux remain FAIL pending explicit metric disposition; actual accent clipping is fixed on the finite corpus. Phase10 and production NO-GO; automatic execution false. No deletion scope, protected approval, model qualification or controller activation is supplied.
> >
> Current native evidence reruns1448backend/1031frontend,51affected Windows browser(2+49, exact membership), separate import8/MariaDB90+3/RD216/PDF admission1/Linux8, offline83+realDocling14, baseline math5, TypeScript/lint/build and both-platform PDF checks. The preceding380ordinary/53specialized/browser/helper/runtime/model totals below describe the historical accepted26d531c snapshot, **not fresh current executions**. The19combined handoff tests replace overlapping bootstrap7/old18. Current report/process/source binding is authoritative; original historical bytes remain in Git26d531c. > Current native evidence reruns1448backend/1031frontend,51affected Windows browser(2+49, exact membership), separate import8/MariaDB90+3/RD216/PDF admission1/Linux8, offline83+realDocling14, baseline math5, TypeScript/lint/build and both-platform PDF checks. The preceding380ordinary/53specialized/browser/helper/runtime/model totals below describe the historical accepted26d531c snapshot, **not fresh current executions**. The19combined handoff tests replace overlapping bootstrap7/old18. Current report/process/source binding is authoritative; original historical bytes remain in Git26d531c.
@@ -1,3 +1,5 @@
> **30 October 2026 — metric-only owner approval recorded.** See [S01_APPROVAL.md](S01_APPROVAL.md). Revised S01 now passes36/36 per platform under the approved same2mm vertical baseline metric; original28/20 failures remain unchanged. Human PDF spacing remains PARTIAL; Phase10 and production NO-GO. This supersedes only the metric-pending statements below.
> **P10-ENTRY-FINAL addendum — 30 October 2026 (Europe/Paris).** The revised-name clipping correction is application commit154a9e8; the current source-bound candidate is in ACCEPTANCE.json/ENTRY_PROPOSAL.json. Read [the complete current report](../../../p10-entry-final/REPORT.md), [native PDF guide](../../../p10-entry-final/REVIEW_GUIDE.md) and [owner actions](../../../p10-entry-final/OWNER_REVIEW.md). Original S01 failures28Windows/20Linux remain FAIL pending explicit metric disposition; actual accent clipping is fixed on the finite corpus. Phase10 and production NO-GO; automatic execution false. No deletion scope, protected approval, model qualification or controller activation is supplied. > **P10-ENTRY-FINAL addendum — 30 October 2026 (Europe/Paris).** The revised-name clipping correction is application commit154a9e8; the current source-bound candidate is in ACCEPTANCE.json/ENTRY_PROPOSAL.json. Read [the complete current report](../../../p10-entry-final/REPORT.md), [native PDF guide](../../../p10-entry-final/REVIEW_GUIDE.md) and [owner actions](../../../p10-entry-final/OWNER_REVIEW.md). Original S01 failures28Windows/20Linux remain FAIL pending explicit metric disposition; actual accent clipping is fixed on the finite corpus. Phase10 and production NO-GO; automatic execution false. No deletion scope, protected approval, model qualification or controller activation is supplied.
> >
> Current native evidence reruns1448backend/1031frontend,51affected Windows browser(2+49, exact membership), separate import8/MariaDB90+3/RD216/PDF admission1/Linux8, offline83+realDocling14, baseline math5, TypeScript/lint/build and both-platform PDF checks. The preceding380ordinary/53specialized/browser/helper/runtime/model totals below describe the historical accepted26d531c snapshot, **not fresh current executions**. The19combined handoff tests replace overlapping bootstrap7/old18. Current report/process/source binding is authoritative; original historical bytes remain in Git26d531c. > Current native evidence reruns1448backend/1031frontend,51affected Windows browser(2+49, exact membership), separate import8/MariaDB90+3/RD216/PDF admission1/Linux8, offline83+realDocling14, baseline math5, TypeScript/lint/build and both-platform PDF checks. The preceding380ordinary/53specialized/browser/helper/runtime/model totals below describe the historical accepted26d531c snapshot, **not fresh current executions**. The19combined handoff tests replace overlapping bootstrap7/old18. Current report/process/source binding is authoritative; original historical bytes remain in Git26d531c.
@@ -1,3 +1,5 @@
> **30 October 2026 — metric-only owner approval recorded.** See [S01_APPROVAL.md](S01_APPROVAL.md). Revised S01 now passes36/36 per platform under the approved same2mm vertical baseline metric; original28/20 failures remain unchanged. Human PDF spacing remains PARTIAL; Phase10 and production NO-GO. This supersedes only the metric-pending statements below.
> **P10-ENTRY-FINAL addendum — 30 October 2026 (Europe/Paris).** The revised-name clipping correction is application commit154a9e8; the current source-bound candidate is in ACCEPTANCE.json/ENTRY_PROPOSAL.json. Read [the complete current report](../../../p10-entry-final/REPORT.md), [native PDF guide](../../../p10-entry-final/REVIEW_GUIDE.md) and [owner actions](../../../p10-entry-final/OWNER_REVIEW.md). Original S01 failures28Windows/20Linux remain FAIL pending explicit metric disposition; actual accent clipping is fixed on the finite corpus. Phase10 and production NO-GO; automatic execution false. No deletion scope, protected approval, model qualification or controller activation is supplied. > **P10-ENTRY-FINAL addendum — 30 October 2026 (Europe/Paris).** The revised-name clipping correction is application commit154a9e8; the current source-bound candidate is in ACCEPTANCE.json/ENTRY_PROPOSAL.json. Read [the complete current report](../../../p10-entry-final/REPORT.md), [native PDF guide](../../../p10-entry-final/REVIEW_GUIDE.md) and [owner actions](../../../p10-entry-final/OWNER_REVIEW.md). Original S01 failures28Windows/20Linux remain FAIL pending explicit metric disposition; actual accent clipping is fixed on the finite corpus. Phase10 and production NO-GO; automatic execution false. No deletion scope, protected approval, model qualification or controller activation is supplied.
> >
> Current native evidence reruns1448backend/1031frontend,51affected Windows browser(2+49, exact membership), separate import8/MariaDB90+3/RD216/PDF admission1/Linux8, offline83+realDocling14, baseline math5, TypeScript/lint/build and both-platform PDF checks. The preceding380ordinary/53specialized/browser/helper/runtime/model totals below describe the historical accepted26d531c snapshot, **not fresh current executions**. The19combined handoff tests replace overlapping bootstrap7/old18. Current report/process/source binding is authoritative; original historical bytes remain in Git26d531c. > Current native evidence reruns1448backend/1031frontend,51affected Windows browser(2+49, exact membership), separate import8/MariaDB90+3/RD216/PDF admission1/Linux8, offline83+realDocling14, baseline math5, TypeScript/lint/build and both-platform PDF checks. The preceding380ordinary/53specialized/browser/helper/runtime/model totals below describe the historical accepted26d531c snapshot, **not fresh current executions**. The19combined handoff tests replace overlapping bootstrap7/old18. Current report/process/source binding is authoritative; original historical bytes remain in Git26d531c.
@@ -1,3 +1,5 @@
> **30 October 2026 — metric-only owner approval recorded.** See [S01_APPROVAL.md](S01_APPROVAL.md). Revised S01 now passes36/36 per platform under the approved same2mm vertical baseline metric; original28/20 failures remain unchanged. Human PDF spacing remains PARTIAL; Phase10 and production NO-GO. This supersedes only the metric-pending statements below.
> **P10-ENTRY-FINAL addendum — 30 October 2026 (Europe/Paris).** The revised-name clipping correction is application commit154a9e8; the current source-bound candidate is in ACCEPTANCE.json/ENTRY_PROPOSAL.json. Read [the complete current report](../../../p10-entry-final/REPORT.md), [native PDF guide](../../../p10-entry-final/REVIEW_GUIDE.md) and [owner actions](../../../p10-entry-final/OWNER_REVIEW.md). Original S01 failures28Windows/20Linux remain FAIL pending explicit metric disposition; actual accent clipping is fixed on the finite corpus. Phase10 and production NO-GO; automatic execution false. No deletion scope, protected approval, model qualification or controller activation is supplied. > **P10-ENTRY-FINAL addendum — 30 October 2026 (Europe/Paris).** The revised-name clipping correction is application commit154a9e8; the current source-bound candidate is in ACCEPTANCE.json/ENTRY_PROPOSAL.json. Read [the complete current report](../../../p10-entry-final/REPORT.md), [native PDF guide](../../../p10-entry-final/REVIEW_GUIDE.md) and [owner actions](../../../p10-entry-final/OWNER_REVIEW.md). Original S01 failures28Windows/20Linux remain FAIL pending explicit metric disposition; actual accent clipping is fixed on the finite corpus. Phase10 and production NO-GO; automatic execution false. No deletion scope, protected approval, model qualification or controller activation is supplied.
> >
> Current native evidence reruns1448backend/1031frontend,51affected Windows browser(2+49, exact membership), separate import8/MariaDB90+3/RD216/PDF admission1/Linux8, offline83+realDocling14, baseline math5, TypeScript/lint/build and both-platform PDF checks. The preceding380ordinary/53specialized/browser/helper/runtime/model totals below describe the historical accepted26d531c snapshot, **not fresh current executions**. The19combined handoff tests replace overlapping bootstrap7/old18. Current report/process/source binding is authoritative; original historical bytes remain in Git26d531c. > Current native evidence reruns1448backend/1031frontend,51affected Windows browser(2+49, exact membership), separate import8/MariaDB90+3/RD216/PDF admission1/Linux8, offline83+realDocling14, baseline math5, TypeScript/lint/build and both-platform PDF checks. The preceding380ordinary/53specialized/browser/helper/runtime/model totals below describe the historical accepted26d531c snapshot, **not fresh current executions**. The19combined handoff tests replace overlapping bootstrap7/old18. Current report/process/source binding is authoritative; original historical bytes remain in Git26d531c.
@@ -1,3 +1,5 @@
> **30 October 2026 — metric-only owner approval recorded.** See [S01_APPROVAL.md](S01_APPROVAL.md). Revised S01 now passes36/36 per platform under the approved same2mm vertical baseline metric; original28/20 failures remain unchanged. Human PDF spacing remains PARTIAL; Phase10 and production NO-GO. This supersedes only the metric-pending statements below.
> **P10-ENTRY-FINAL addendum — 30 October 2026 (Europe/Paris).** The revised-name clipping correction is application commit154a9e8; the current source-bound candidate is in ACCEPTANCE.json/ENTRY_PROPOSAL.json. Read [the complete current report](../../../p10-entry-final/REPORT.md), [native PDF guide](../../../p10-entry-final/REVIEW_GUIDE.md) and [owner actions](../../../p10-entry-final/OWNER_REVIEW.md). Original S01 failures28Windows/20Linux remain FAIL pending explicit metric disposition; actual accent clipping is fixed on the finite corpus. Phase10 and production NO-GO; automatic execution false. No deletion scope, protected approval, model qualification or controller activation is supplied. > **P10-ENTRY-FINAL addendum — 30 October 2026 (Europe/Paris).** The revised-name clipping correction is application commit154a9e8; the current source-bound candidate is in ACCEPTANCE.json/ENTRY_PROPOSAL.json. Read [the complete current report](../../../p10-entry-final/REPORT.md), [native PDF guide](../../../p10-entry-final/REVIEW_GUIDE.md) and [owner actions](../../../p10-entry-final/OWNER_REVIEW.md). Original S01 failures28Windows/20Linux remain FAIL pending explicit metric disposition; actual accent clipping is fixed on the finite corpus. Phase10 and production NO-GO; automatic execution false. No deletion scope, protected approval, model qualification or controller activation is supplied.
> >
> Current native evidence reruns1448backend/1031frontend,51affected Windows browser(2+49, exact membership), separate import8/MariaDB90+3/RD216/PDF admission1/Linux8, offline83+realDocling14, baseline math5, TypeScript/lint/build and both-platform PDF checks. The preceding380ordinary/53specialized/browser/helper/runtime/model totals below describe the historical accepted26d531c snapshot, **not fresh current executions**. The19combined handoff tests replace overlapping bootstrap7/old18. Current report/process/source binding is authoritative; original historical bytes remain in Git26d531c. > Current native evidence reruns1448backend/1031frontend,51affected Windows browser(2+49, exact membership), separate import8/MariaDB90+3/RD216/PDF admission1/Linux8, offline83+realDocling14, baseline math5, TypeScript/lint/build and both-platform PDF checks. The preceding380ordinary/53specialized/browser/helper/runtime/model totals below describe the historical accepted26d531c snapshot, **not fresh current executions**. The19combined handoff tests replace overlapping bootstrap7/old18. Current report/process/source binding is authoritative; original historical bytes remain in Git26d531c.
@@ -0,0 +1,21 @@
# Revised S01 metric disposition —30 October2026
The owner replied **“Approve the revised S01 metric only”** to the explicit question for candidate `ba04d817fed26d659bfa2a56b089d6cac851dc34`. [The recorded scope](S01_METRIC_APPROVAL.json) is included in the immutable verifier-source manifest. This records the direct human decision; it is not a controller signing key, protected entry approval or manufactured visual acceptance.
The approved change applies only to the **vertical S01 position in revised designVersion2**, measured baseline-to-baseline with the **same2mm limit**. Horizontal position remains2mm. Original version1 checks, all other marker positions, font size, color, pages, membership, physical bounds, content, name ink and sidebar checks remain enforced. The old script, references, PDFs and raw Windows28/Linux20 failures are unchanged. No application code or rendered document changed in this follow-up.
The approved gate requalifies the existing source-bound native corpus: **Windows36/36 and Linux36/36 PASS**. Baseline differences remain at most0.227378mm and0.367938mm. This is a new evaluation of existing native evidence, not72 newly rendered PDFs or extra browser tests. The verifier recomputes geometry from the recorded DOM/native baselines, verifies PDF hashes/design version/membership, and retains every unrelated original failure. It does not trust a claimed zero delta. `s01-approved-qualification` and its actual process are indexed in TEST_EVIDENCE.json.
Six new unit cases were introduced RED then GREEN. They cover the approved substitution and reject excessive horizontal/vertical movement, page/font/color failures, unrelated failures, missing/duplicate/foreign/version1 evidence and nonfinite/false coordinate claims. Two additional package tampering tests reject a broadened approval or failing baseline. **The current combined suite is27PASS**, replacing the overlapping prior19. The actual native source/command/identity report is indexed; this is not a fresh backend/frontend/browser regression run.
The first combined run passed26/27: changing the imported approval file was ignored because verification used the unchanged trusted approval and artifact. Actual geometry stayed limited to2mm. The package now also rejects an inconsistent imported file; the same negative case passed in the final27/27 run. The failed attempt is retained under `.artifacts/p10-entry-final/verifier-final-20261030T072210Z/` and contributes no passing total.
PDF-S01-01 is CLOSED for this metric decision. Automated PDF Fidelity is PASS for the finite qualified corpus under the explicitly approved metric. PDF Spacing remains PARTIAL because human typography review is pending. The original raw oracle reports remain PARTIAL/nonzero, preserving their historical result rather than relabelling it.
**Still pending:** review the [actual native PDFs](../../../p10-entry-final/REVIEW_GUIDE.md), including name/title spacing, paragraph rhythm, short/long/dense pages, sidebars, photos and matching letters; real device/AT/language and physical printing; protected Phase10 baseline/scope decisions; actual controller sign-in/key/runtime/composite adapter/policy qualification. Existing CV-model, hosted CI, Python/security/infrastructure limitations remain independently recorded. Five conditional-development requests remain requested, not granted or executable.
Candidate remainsba04d817; resolve the final clean published envelope HEAD and verify its remote independently using `node docs/automation/handoffs/pre-phase10/verify.mjs --verify-remote`. Protected entry still returns native exit3. **Phase10 NO-GO, automatic execution false, production NO-GO.** No model activation, cleanup, main merge, deployment or separate-controller operation occurred.
This addendum supersedes only the earlier statements that PDF metric approval is pending in the26/29October historical reports. Their measured evidence, original failures and all unrelated acceptance limitations remain intact.
Final fresh-context read-only review of9267cab through1a47f7a and the pending addenda found no actionable issues, rulings or deferred minors. It checked metric scope, immutable approval binding, preservation and evidence accounting, including the27/27 native test record. It did not supply human visual/printing acceptance, run product suites, verify remote publication or deploy. Final clean-envelope/publication verification follows separately.
@@ -3,7 +3,7 @@
"workstreamId": "AUTOMATION-HANDOFF-01", "workstreamId": "AUTOMATION-HANDOFF-01",
"kind": "TEST_EVIDENCE", "kind": "TEST_EVIDENCE",
"testedCommit": "ba04d817fed26d659bfa2a56b089d6cac851dc34", "testedCommit": "ba04d817fed26d659bfa2a56b089d6cac851dc34",
"verifierCommit": "52fb91e023d39d2087f6d0a89ad367bfc466027c", "verifierCommit": "1a47f7ac1d9cddd647135ebee808a77301335016",
"verifierSourceArtifactId": "verifier-source", "verifierSourceArtifactId": "verifier-source",
"sourceManifestArtifactId": "application-source-before", "sourceManifestArtifactId": "application-source-before",
"sourceAfterArtifactId": "application-source-after", "sourceAfterArtifactId": "application-source-after",
@@ -858,12 +858,6 @@
"sha256": "c6cf652658e6c621d953325fa6b3875a5993b71973282f9989b2bb52e1629222", "sha256": "c6cf652658e6c621d953325fa6b3875a5993b71973282f9989b2bb52e1629222",
"description": "One-off bounded QA producer source, not an execution policy or roadmap controller" "description": "One-off bounded QA producer source, not an execution policy or roadmap controller"
}, },
{
"id": "verifier-source",
"path": "evidence/verifier-source.gz",
"sha256": "fcf0d8cd73825e534a3f75a6044f78810c888f30f119e0dba36f4623ec880ac8",
"description": "Native source-bound qualification evidence"
},
{ {
"id": "controller-current-SINGLE_USER_ACCEPTANCE-md", "id": "controller-current-SINGLE_USER_ACCEPTANCE-md",
"path": "evidence/controller-current-SINGLE_USER_ACCEPTANCE-md.gz", "path": "evidence/controller-current-SINGLE_USER_ACCEPTANCE-md.gz",
@@ -1601,34 +1595,58 @@
"sha256": "548006ba92faf65eadaf8343493b8a7a0709325440f28e4c7c764c4ba7593e3b", "sha256": "548006ba92faf65eadaf8343493b8a7a0709325440f28e4c7c764c4ba7593e3b",
"description": "One-off bounded QA producer, not a roadmap executor" "description": "One-off bounded QA producer, not a roadmap executor"
}, },
{
"id": "s01-metric-approval",
"path": "evidence/s01-metric-approval.gz",
"sha256": "b90a87221ed7176594654b2cbd3e4a97142533d748c78fd8daabd7a2eb21b814",
"description": "Scoped human-approved revised S01 qualification; no visual/entry/production approval"
},
{
"id": "s01-approved-qualification",
"path": "evidence/s01-approved-qualification.gz",
"sha256": "fa5b5efe4d7c3ed48a109545ad0abb2834e8e26e111b9d20ecb9d4284b0629c2",
"description": "Scoped human-approved revised S01 qualification; no visual/entry/production approval"
},
{
"id": "s01-qualification-process",
"path": "evidence/s01-qualification-process.gz",
"sha256": "bb1b1ccfb03bd888e5e429f5a17c4c106246cfb852b990298236edc7c86c7016",
"description": "Scoped human-approved revised S01 qualification; no visual/entry/production approval"
},
{
"id": "verifier-source",
"path": "evidence/verifier-source.gz",
"sha256": "e76de49d94de3cc9dacc34fd8f2a6546a6612f3f00976064d9a3c3088beacdbd",
"description": "Scoped human-approved revised S01 qualification; no visual/entry/production approval"
},
{ {
"id": "p10-entry-proposal", "id": "p10-entry-proposal",
"path": "evidence/p10-entry-proposal.gz", "path": "evidence/p10-entry-proposal.gz",
"sha256": "c526b7774aa5989fa5f02a1e1cf95069f72323fc9888312753f81dfbee45ff45", "sha256": "0a70b05b01a1468e4ff813d11ba33e763996a63d5e0dd9f0de0fd2d62a2e7104",
"description": "Evidence-only owner proposal or fixed schema; no protected approval or executable policy" "description": "Scoped human-approved revised S01 qualification; no visual/entry/production approval"
}, },
{ {
"id": "p10-entry-proposal-schema", "id": "p10-entry-proposal-schema",
"path": "evidence/p10-entry-proposal-schema.gz", "path": "evidence/p10-entry-proposal-schema.gz",
"sha256": "f8a13d26b2b4ab2ba5532e636e114a94ae09c5f884ba0333db9a415d2c4acf59", "sha256": "3d2f684f2cb608b76297d16293e19415ca6f02cfcee74446880dc845641b3f1e",
"description": "Evidence-only owner proposal or fixed schema; no protected approval or executable policy" "description": "Scoped human-approved revised S01 qualification; no visual/entry/production approval"
}, },
{ {
"id": "verifier-process", "id": "verifier-process",
"path": "evidence/verifier-process.gz", "path": "evidence/verifier-process.gz",
"sha256": "d09e03928eb9f6215239419298b8077b3edc8d6b93d0e65fbf46f8cef3d33e62", "sha256": "58fbde6eeec013acf6e6039dc17443f918e7258a2d3bec59a54955a73eb23b07",
"description": "Final19 combined unit/package negative tests, exact source and native process; supersedes overlapping bootstrap7/old18" "description": "Final27 combined unit/package negative tests, exact source and native process; supersedes overlapping old19"
}, },
{ {
"id": "handoff-validator-native", "id": "handoff-validator-native",
"path": "evidence/handoff-validator-native.gz", "path": "evidence/handoff-validator-native.gz",
"sha256": "abbad0415806b36a139ae6c07988be65ceb9e6193166214e719ca64d7fa59136", "sha256": "49122a150619736a99b0911f9c18441d515c336f3eebab55be345fba56563a62",
"description": "Final19 combined unit/package negative tests, exact source and native process; supersedes overlapping bootstrap7/old18" "description": "Final27 combined unit/package negative tests, exact source and native process; supersedes overlapping old19"
}, },
{ {
"id": "p10-final-gate-processes", "id": "p10-final-gate-processes",
"path": "evidence/p10-final-gate-processes.gz", "path": "evidence/p10-final-gate-processes.gz",
"sha256": "e80d677ceae2b28e9dee55c2d6ee8fac93c93bd310e1354564caa31ee681a248", "sha256": "1f544cdd3e2efaebe8864604bd7eb7b9dc5dcb5cf2040cc1781cebc79c89fc93",
"description": "Actual companion schema/negative and native blocked-entry observations; not product-case totals or protected approval" "description": "Actual companion schema/negative and native blocked-entry observations; not product-case totals or protected approval"
}, },
{ {
@@ -1640,7 +1658,7 @@
{ {
"id": "p10-protected-entry-native", "id": "p10-protected-entry-native",
"path": "evidence/p10-protected-entry-native.gz", "path": "evidence/p10-protected-entry-native.gz",
"sha256": "f2f15d04ad09336d593564afd09bffada58a6b61897e7d749db4fa6030b4a602", "sha256": "2c8d977d0b4e9dcfcc120017c44da9ad6738cfac01874815d32e701f3231128d",
"description": "Actual companion schema/negative and native blocked-entry observations; not product-case totals or protected approval" "description": "Actual companion schema/negative and native blocked-entry observations; not product-case totals or protected approval"
}, },
{ {
@@ -1648,6 +1666,18 @@
"path": "evidence/p10-proposal-check-source.gz", "path": "evidence/p10-proposal-check-source.gz",
"sha256": "d0505e74d05557e2a7fd64807e5cc1967695413e3e038e83485f7dcaad9c9557", "sha256": "d0505e74d05557e2a7fd64807e5cc1967695413e3e038e83485f7dcaad9c9557",
"description": "Actual companion schema/negative and native blocked-entry observations; not product-case totals or protected approval" "description": "Actual companion schema/negative and native blocked-entry observations; not product-case totals or protected approval"
},
{
"id": "s01-initial-package-negative-log",
"path": "evidence/s01-initial-package-negative-log.gz",
"sha256": "17cb306762818cda32671a18b05833dc8a5009de53e365115d95152124717bab",
"description": "Superseded26/27 regression attempt: copied approval inconsistency detected and fixed; final27 replaces this, not additive"
},
{
"id": "s01-initial-package-negative-process",
"path": "evidence/s01-initial-package-negative-process.gz",
"sha256": "ae8141e2ab46517d68ccb9d8338d4e7670fe8880327c7735c883cdb5d0eb3050",
"description": "Superseded26/27 regression attempt: copied approval inconsistency detected and fixed; final27 replaces this, not additive"
} }
], ],
"reports": [ "reports": [
@@ -2284,8 +2314,8 @@
{ {
"id": "handoff-validator", "id": "handoff-validator",
"bindingScope": "HANDOFF_VERIFIER", "bindingScope": "HANDOFF_VERIFIER",
"sourceCommit": "52fb91e023d39d2087f6d0a89ad367bfc466027c", "sourceCommit": "1a47f7ac1d9cddd647135ebee808a77301335016",
"executedFromCommit": "ba04d817fed26d659bfa2a56b089d6cac851dc34", "executedFromCommit": "1a47f7ac1d9cddd647135ebee808a77301335016",
"status": "PASS", "status": "PASS",
"exitCode": 0, "exitCode": 0,
"artifactId": "handoff-validator-native", "artifactId": "handoff-validator-native",
@@ -2293,20 +2323,41 @@
"processPointer": "/exitCode", "processPointer": "/exitCode",
"nativeFormat": "node-test", "nativeFormat": "node-test",
"counts": { "counts": {
"passed": 19, "passed": 27,
"failed": 0, "failed": 0,
"skipped": 0, "skipped": 0,
"retries": 0, "retries": 0,
"unexecuted": 0 "unexecuted": 0
}, },
"membershipSha256": "650c74731099d11b93ac03a846ae05407c00b5d2442073c89d220118b0e1eb20", "membershipSha256": "8052c122a6348a82e8740b97a92e7bd64ff2ce11f01102871a96469c2d6f229d",
"limits": "Final combined19; no invented approval; excludes overlapping bootstrap7/old18. Native execution commit retained separately from verifier source snapshot." "limits": "Final combined27; no invented approval; excludes overlapping old19. Native execution commit retained separately from verifier source snapshot."
},
{
"id": "s01-approved-qualification",
"bindingScope": "HANDOFF_VERIFIER",
"sourceCommit": "1a47f7ac1d9cddd647135ebee808a77301335016",
"executedFromCommit": "1a47f7ac1d9cddd647135ebee808a77301335016",
"status": "PASS",
"exitCode": 0,
"artifactId": "s01-approved-qualification",
"processArtifactId": "s01-qualification-process",
"processPointer": "/exitCode",
"nativeFormat": null,
"counts": {
"passed": 0,
"failed": 0,
"skipped": 0,
"retries": 0,
"unexecuted": 0
},
"membershipSha256": "4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945",
"limits": "72 existing source-bound native documents requalified with owner-approved same2mm S01 vertical baseline metric. All other failures retained; no new PDF rendering, product cases or human approval."
}, },
{ {
"id": "p10-proposal-schema", "id": "p10-proposal-schema",
"bindingScope": "APPLICATION", "bindingScope": "APPLICATION",
"sourceCommit": "ba04d817fed26d659bfa2a56b089d6cac851dc34", "sourceCommit": "ba04d817fed26d659bfa2a56b089d6cac851dc34",
"executedFromCommit": "ba04d817fed26d659bfa2a56b089d6cac851dc34", "executedFromCommit": "1a47f7ac1d9cddd647135ebee808a77301335016",
"status": "PASS", "status": "PASS",
"exitCode": 0, "exitCode": 0,
"artifactId": "p10-proposal-check-native", "artifactId": "p10-proposal-check-native",
@@ -2327,7 +2378,7 @@
"id": "p10-protected-entry", "id": "p10-protected-entry",
"bindingScope": "APPLICATION", "bindingScope": "APPLICATION",
"sourceCommit": "ba04d817fed26d659bfa2a56b089d6cac851dc34", "sourceCommit": "ba04d817fed26d659bfa2a56b089d6cac851dc34",
"executedFromCommit": "ba04d817fed26d659bfa2a56b089d6cac851dc34", "executedFromCommit": "1a47f7ac1d9cddd647135ebee808a77301335016",
"status": "BLOCKED", "status": "BLOCKED",
"exitCode": 3, "exitCode": 3,
"artifactId": "p10-protected-entry-native", "artifactId": "p10-protected-entry-native",
@@ -1,3 +1,5 @@
> **30 October 2026 — metric-only owner approval recorded.** See [S01_APPROVAL.md](S01_APPROVAL.md). Revised S01 now passes36/36 per platform under the approved same2mm vertical baseline metric; original28/20 failures remain unchanged. Human PDF spacing remains PARTIAL; Phase10 and production NO-GO. This supersedes only the metric-pending statements below.
> **P10-ENTRY-FINAL addendum — 30 October 2026 (Europe/Paris).** The revised-name clipping correction is application commit154a9e8; the current source-bound candidate is in ACCEPTANCE.json/ENTRY_PROPOSAL.json. Read [the complete current report](../../../p10-entry-final/REPORT.md), [native PDF guide](../../../p10-entry-final/REVIEW_GUIDE.md) and [owner actions](../../../p10-entry-final/OWNER_REVIEW.md). Original S01 failures28Windows/20Linux remain FAIL pending explicit metric disposition; actual accent clipping is fixed on the finite corpus. Phase10 and production NO-GO; automatic execution false. No deletion scope, protected approval, model qualification or controller activation is supplied. > **P10-ENTRY-FINAL addendum — 30 October 2026 (Europe/Paris).** The revised-name clipping correction is application commit154a9e8; the current source-bound candidate is in ACCEPTANCE.json/ENTRY_PROPOSAL.json. Read [the complete current report](../../../p10-entry-final/REPORT.md), [native PDF guide](../../../p10-entry-final/REVIEW_GUIDE.md) and [owner actions](../../../p10-entry-final/OWNER_REVIEW.md). Original S01 failures28Windows/20Linux remain FAIL pending explicit metric disposition; actual accent clipping is fixed on the finite corpus. Phase10 and production NO-GO; automatic execution false. No deletion scope, protected approval, model qualification or controller activation is supplied.
> >
> Current native evidence reruns1448backend/1031frontend,51affected Windows browser(2+49, exact membership), separate import8/MariaDB90+3/RD216/PDF admission1/Linux8, offline83+realDocling14, baseline math5, TypeScript/lint/build and both-platform PDF checks. The preceding380ordinary/53specialized/browser/helper/runtime/model totals below describe the historical accepted26d531c snapshot, **not fresh current executions**. The19combined handoff tests replace overlapping bootstrap7/old18. Current report/process/source binding is authoritative; original historical bytes remain in Git26d531c. > Current native evidence reruns1448backend/1031frontend,51affected Windows browser(2+49, exact membership), separate import8/MariaDB90+3/RD216/PDF admission1/Linux8, offline83+realDocling14, baseline math5, TypeScript/lint/build and both-platform PDF checks. The preceding380ordinary/53specialized/browser/helper/runtime/model totals below describe the historical accepted26d531c snapshot, **not fresh current executions**. The19combined handoff tests replace overlapping bootstrap7/old18. Current report/process/source binding is authoritative; original historical bytes remain in Git26d531c.
@@ -1,3 +1,5 @@
> **30 October 2026 — metric-only owner approval recorded.** See [S01_APPROVAL.md](S01_APPROVAL.md). Revised S01 now passes36/36 per platform under the approved same2mm vertical baseline metric; original28/20 failures remain unchanged. Human PDF spacing remains PARTIAL; Phase10 and production NO-GO. This supersedes only the metric-pending statements below.
> **P10-ENTRY-FINAL addendum — 30 October 2026 (Europe/Paris).** The revised-name clipping correction is application commit154a9e8; the current source-bound candidate is in ACCEPTANCE.json/ENTRY_PROPOSAL.json. Read [the complete current report](../../../p10-entry-final/REPORT.md), [native PDF guide](../../../p10-entry-final/REVIEW_GUIDE.md) and [owner actions](../../../p10-entry-final/OWNER_REVIEW.md). Original S01 failures28Windows/20Linux remain FAIL pending explicit metric disposition; actual accent clipping is fixed on the finite corpus. Phase10 and production NO-GO; automatic execution false. No deletion scope, protected approval, model qualification or controller activation is supplied. > **P10-ENTRY-FINAL addendum — 30 October 2026 (Europe/Paris).** The revised-name clipping correction is application commit154a9e8; the current source-bound candidate is in ACCEPTANCE.json/ENTRY_PROPOSAL.json. Read [the complete current report](../../../p10-entry-final/REPORT.md), [native PDF guide](../../../p10-entry-final/REVIEW_GUIDE.md) and [owner actions](../../../p10-entry-final/OWNER_REVIEW.md). Original S01 failures28Windows/20Linux remain FAIL pending explicit metric disposition; actual accent clipping is fixed on the finite corpus. Phase10 and production NO-GO; automatic execution false. No deletion scope, protected approval, model qualification or controller activation is supplied.
> >
> Current native evidence reruns1448backend/1031frontend,51affected Windows browser(2+49, exact membership), separate import8/MariaDB90+3/RD216/PDF admission1/Linux8, offline83+realDocling14, baseline math5, TypeScript/lint/build and both-platform PDF checks. The preceding380ordinary/53specialized/browser/helper/runtime/model totals below describe the historical accepted26d531c snapshot, **not fresh current executions**. The19combined handoff tests replace overlapping bootstrap7/old18. Current report/process/source binding is authoritative; original historical bytes remain in Git26d531c. > Current native evidence reruns1448backend/1031frontend,51affected Windows browser(2+49, exact membership), separate import8/MariaDB90+3/RD216/PDF admission1/Linux8, offline83+realDocling14, baseline math5, TypeScript/lint/build and both-platform PDF checks. The preceding380ordinary/53specialized/browser/helper/runtime/model totals below describe the historical accepted26d531c snapshot, **not fresh current executions**. The19combined handoff tests replace overlapping bootstrap7/old18. Current report/process/source binding is authoritative; original historical bytes remain in Git26d531c.