docs(redesign): record Rules draft repair acceptance

This commit is contained in:
cesnimda
2026-10-09 19:35:07 +02:00
parent 30f513d0c9
commit 339e3ba591
28 changed files with 1406 additions and 90 deletions
+11 -3
View File
@@ -1,8 +1,16 @@
# P5-15 — Phase 5 final acceptance
## P5-15-01R-01 — Current bounded saved-search successor
## P5-15-01R-02 — Current bounded Rules successor
[Saved-search repair and evidence](p5-15-01/saved-search-repair/README.md) resolves the native SQLite GET500 and hidden error. PRES-J02 moves FAIL→PARTIAL; current57 totals are **0PASS/54PARTIAL/2FAIL/1DEFERRED/0BLOCKED/0NOT VERIFIED**. The01 audit remains historical below. AUTH-01 Analytics query loss and SETTINGS-01 Rules draft loss stay open/failing; no automatic P2 repair or P5-15-02 progression is authorized. Production remains NO-GO; `main` is unchanged. P5-13 stays deferred/unqualified/Production-withheld with0/366calls,0human reviews and no review UI.
[Rules draft repair and native evidence](p5-15-01/rules-draft-repair/README.md) closes SETTINGS-01 for verified internal session retention, Save/readback, validation, failure/retry, Discard and account disposal. PRES-S03 moves FAIL→PARTIAL; current57 totals are **0PASS/55PARTIAL/1FAIL/1DEFERRED/0BLOCKED/0NOT VERIFIED**. AUTH-01 Analytics query loss remains open/failing. The prior audit/R-01 records below remain historical; other Settings reliability and human/provider acceptance remain open.
Completed repair commit `30f513d0c993800ec5d5583329ed65dc7ec9a8d4` is independently pushed. **R-02: GO for the bounded Rules repair.** Fresh backend1,033 / frontend472(+8) / ordinary browser128pass+1fail(+4cases) / standalone diagnostics2pass+0fail. All117inherited, four Rules and three saved-search repair browser cases pass; AUTH-01 remains the one ordinary failure. Sidecar49, focusedAI108, realHTTP2, revision5, standard fidelity16/16(36=36), settings exports8/8(24=24) and security/config9/6/1/3 pass. [Exact results and limits](p5-15-01/rules-draft-repair/README.md#fresh-validation-and-diagnostic-reconciliation) distinguish subsets and local proof. Full267axe scans have0reported violations and2,040incomplete node occurrences; human/device acceptance remains open. [Intermittent CV observation](p5-15-01/INTERMITTENT_FAILURES.md) remains OPEN despite fresh passing frontend/native runs. Final documentation/repository check evidence is retained with the repair.
**Production remains NO-GO; main unchanged. P5-15-02 is neither started nor cleared.** No Analytics, P5-13, Docker, B07 or deployment work. P5-13 remains deferred/unqualified/Production-withheld:0/366qualification calls,0human reviews, no review UI.
## Historical P5-15-01R-01 — Saved-search successor
[Saved-search repair and evidence](p5-15-01/saved-search-repair/README.md) resolves the native SQLite GET500 and hidden error. PRES-J02 moves FAIL→PARTIAL; totals at R-01 were **0PASS/54PARTIAL/2FAIL/1DEFERRED/0BLOCKED/0NOT VERIFIED**. The01 audit remains historical below. AUTH-01 Analytics query loss and SETTINGS-01 Rules draft loss remained open/failing at R-01; no automatic P2 repair or P5-15-02 progression was authorized. Production remains NO-GO; `main` is unchanged. P5-13 stays deferred/unqualified/Production-withheld with0/366calls,0human reviews and no review UI.
R-01 fresh results: **backend1,033 / frontend464 / ordinary browser124pass+1fail / separate diagnostics1pass+1fail**. All117 inherited browser cases pass; three new repair cases pass and the original normal/admin saved-search failures are resolved. Sidecar49, focusedAI108, realHTTP2, revision5, fidelity16/16(36=36), settings8/8(24=24) and security/config9/6/1/3 pass. Fresh251axe scans have0reported violations and**1,880incomplete node occurrences**; no human/device acceptance is implied. [Current evidence and limits](p5-15-01/saved-search-repair/README.md#fresh-validation-and-diagnostic-reconciliation) supersede only the named outcomes, not mandatory acceptance scope.
@@ -11,7 +19,7 @@ R-01 fresh results: **backend1,033 / frontend464 / ordinary browser124pass+1fail
**NO-GO for P5-15-02 under its current entry criteria; Production remains NO-GO. Phase5 is not complete.** Audit from `932b962b9038ddb5ad59b982c0199475bfb50454` on the development branch,2026-10-09. [Final01 report](p5-15-01/README.md), [all57 before/after results](p5-15-01/PRES_RESULTS.md), [32-route native census](p5-15-01/ROUTE_RESULTS.md), [journeys/control limits](p5-15-01/JOURNEYS_AND_CONTROLS.md) and [defects](p5-15-01/DEFECTS.md) supersede the **verification status**, not the original contracts or historical evidence, below.
Exact PRES totals at the01 audit: **0PASS /53PARTIAL /3FAIL /1DEFERRED /0BLOCKED /0NOT VERIFIED =57**. FAIL:E02 sign-in return query loss;J02 saved-search SQLite read500/silent empty list;S03 unsaved Rules draft loss on tab change. These were native failures at that checkpoint, not56 assumed defects or an assertion that the audit introduced them. The successor above supersedes J02 only. Other groups retain evidenced sub-behaviors plus explicit long-tail/human/provider gaps.
Exact PRES totals at the01 audit: **0PASS /53PARTIAL /3FAIL /1DEFERRED /0BLOCKED /0NOT VERIFIED =57**. FAIL:E02 sign-in return query loss;J02 saved-search SQLite read500/silent empty list;S03 unsaved Rules draft loss on tab change. These were native failures at that checkpoint, not56 assumed defects or an assertion that the audit introduced them. R-01 supersedes J02; R-02 supersedes S03 for its verified bounded scope. Other groups retain evidenced sub-behaviors plus explicit long-tail/human/provider gaps.
All32patterns reached expected entry/refresh states for three identities (**192observations**);188route observations satisfy all asserted conditions/4fail on Discover. Of98selected native GET observations,94meet expected statuses/4fail;94route observations have no selected GET. Broader route workflow disposition30PARTIAL/2FAIL includes Login query return. A route/header is not full workflow acceptance. P1 DISCOVERY-01 blocks dependent progression until a separately authorized, individually pushed owner repair/native regression. P2 AUTH-01/SETTINGS-01 need their own remediation dispositions. No repair is hidden in01.