docs(redesign): record Rules draft repair acceptance

2026-10-09 19:35:07 +02:00
parent 30f513d0c9
commit 339e3ba591
28 changed files with 1406 additions and 90 deletions
@@ -1,6 +1,8 @@
 # P5-15-01 functional defect register

-**R-01 current disposition:** DISCOVERY-01 is **CLOSED for the verified SQLite listing/error/recovery defect** by the [bounded repair](saved-search-repair/README.md). Live deployed-provider qualification and complete PRES-J02 delivery/device acceptance remain open. AUTH-01 and SETTINGS-01 remain P2/OPEN; current reproduced open counts areP0=0/P1=0/P2=2/P3=0. Original reproduction/severity/evidence below remain historical; closing this defect does not erase release blockers or grant full-group PASS.
+**R-02 current disposition:** [Rules draft repair](rules-draft-repair/README.md) closes SETTINGS-01 for verified internal draft retention and related Save/validation/failure/retry/Discard/account isolation. DISCOVERY-01 remains scoped CLOSED by R-01. **AUTH-01 remains P2/OPEN; current reproduced open totals:P0=0/P1=0/P2=1/P3=0.** Fresh complete R-02 ordinary browser128pass/1fail and diagnostics2/2 retain the remaining real failure. Production and P5-15-02 remain NO-GO. Unknown historical Rules/notification/language500 causes and [CV intermittent observation](INTERMITTENT_FAILURES.md) remain open.
+
+**Historical R-01 disposition:** DISCOVERY-01 is **CLOSED for the verified SQLite listing/error/recovery defect** by the [bounded repair](saved-search-repair/README.md). Live deployed-provider qualification and complete PRES-J02 delivery/device acceptance remain open. AUTH-01 and SETTINGS-01 remained P2/OPEN at R-01; reproduced open counts wereP0=0/P1=0/P2=2/P3=0. Original reproduction/severity/evidence below remain historical; closing this defect does not erase release blockers or grant full-group PASS.

 Audit source `932b962b9038ddb5ad59b982c0199475bfb50454`. Findings use synthetic accounts and disposable local data; no production account, provider or infrastructure is exercised. An audit finding is not automatically a regression introduced by Phase 5. Application source is unchanged here; neither source inspection nor an InMemory pass can override a native failure.

@@ -45,7 +47,7 @@ P0 means serious security/data loss; P1 an important broken workflow; P2 limited

 ## P5-15-01-SETTINGS-01 — Unsaved Rules draft disappears on tab change

-**Confirmed P2 / OPEN.** PRES-S03; `/settings` Follow-ups→Notifications→Follow-ups. The original preservation ledger already recorded this risk; native execution now establishes the failure. This is silent loss of an in-progress edit, not deletion or corruption of persisted rules.
+**Confirmed P2 at audit / CLOSED by R-02 for the verified Settings-session draft/save/error scope.** PRES-S03; `/settings` Follow-ups→Notifications→Follow-ups. The original failed observation below remains historical. R-02 retains the single draft above the unmounting tabs and proves explicit Save/error/retry/discard/account behaviour; unknown backend500 causes and other Settings acceptance stay open. This was silent loss of an in-progress edit, not deletion or corruption of persisted rules.

 | Field | Evidence-based finding |
 |---|---|
@@ -66,7 +68,7 @@ The two standalone [preference diagnostics](diagnostics/README.md) assert intend

 | Item | Current disposition / required action |
 |---|---|
-| Unsaved Rules draft on tab change | Confirmed P2 SETTINGS-01 above; native failure is not normalized into a pass |
+| Unsaved Rules draft on tab change | Original native P2 SETTINGS-01 is retained historically; R-02 proves the scoped repair without closing unrelated persistence reliability |
 | Language/notification preference writes | Three native overlap rounds succeeded, including six writes, twelve concurrent reads, persisted readback and reload. Historical language PUT500 and notification SQLite/concurrency failures remain open; **not reproduced in this bounded run** is not fixed. No cause for the historical language500 is established; overlapping Identity writes remain a hypothesis |
 | Company modal failure feedback; command/attachment initial focus races | Earlier finite failure observations remain open. Current passing keyboard/modal fixtures do not prove the historical race or outside-modal feedback debt closed; P5-15-02 triage and 04 owner repair as needed |
 | Board scaling and physical touch | Finite 250-ID parity is functional evidence only; full-result memory/request/DOM growth and real device drag remain unqualified. No arbitrary capacity threshold is invented |
@@ -76,4 +78,4 @@ The two standalone [preference diagnostics](diagnostics/README.md) assert intend

 **No P0 is demonstrated by the collected evidence.** That is a bounded finding, not an exhaustive security certification. At the original audit, P1 saved-search verification and dependent activity were blocked; R-01 now supplies the scoped repair proof; independent audit evidence can still be collected safely.

-Original audit finding totals: **P0 0 / P1 1 / P2 2 / P3 0**. Current open reproduced totals after R-01: **P0 0 / P1 0 / P2 2 / P3 0**. These are three distinct failures, not the same count as failing browser cases: normal/admin cases share DISCOVERY-01; AUTH-01 occupies the anonymous case; SETTINGS-01 is a separate diagnostic. Carried failures/evidence gaps are additional debt, not silently closed or counted as newly reproduced defects.
+Original audit finding totals: **P0 0 / P1 1 / P2 2 / P3 0**. Historical open totals after R-01: **P0 0 / P1 0 / P2 2 / P3 0**; current R-02 totals are **P0 0 / P1 0 / P2 1 / P3 0**. These are three distinct original failures, not the same count as failing browser cases: normal/admin cases shared DISCOVERY-01; AUTH-01 occupies the anonymous case; SETTINGS-01 was a separate diagnostic. Carried failures/evidence gaps are additional debt, not silently closed or counted as newly reproduced defects.