docs(phase10): reconcile acceptance evidence and open qualification gaps

2026-11-02 22:15:59 +01:00
parent 2a4acc179e
commit 6f29ed4cdb
1 changed files with 30 additions and 0 deletions
@@ -0,0 +1,30 @@
+# P10-05 — Acceptance reconciliation (OPEN)
+
+2 November 2026. This is an acceptance work register, not final acceptance. P10-01 CLEAN-20 is the only implemented deletion. P10-02/03 retain reviews found no additional proven-safe candidate. No further cleanup is authorised or needed merely to populate a checkpoint.
+
+## Evidence applicability
+
+Fresh integrity check at continuation from 2a4acc17: all 263 indexed TEST_EVIDENCE artifact hashes match; 1,279 application-source hashes match the accepted source-after manifest, with only the approved App.css absent and zero changed-file mismatches. Paths were resolved under the expected repository/evidence root before reading. This establishes historical source applicability, not fresh execution or a complete independent audit. New reports and native test artifacts are outside the application manifest.
+
+| Required area | Evidence disposition | Remaining limit |
+| --- | --- | --- |
+| Cleanup eligibility | CLEAN-20 blob/callers and narrow approval recorded in P10-00/01 | No additional deletion proven |
+| Frontend types/lint/build | PASSED fresh for CSS deletion; P10-01 | Full-suite execution is not represented by these checks |
+| Focused browser EN/NB/theme/responsive | PASSED five selected cases; P10-01 | Canary is not full browser regression or device acceptance |
+| Backend document/data contracts | PASSED 89 selected cases; P10-04 | Not complete backend regression |
+| Frontend document workflows | PASSED 92 selected tests; P10-04 | Not complete frontend regression |
+| Routes/capabilities | Existing 34-route and 57-group reconciliation retained | 56 PARTIAL / one DEFERRED is not 57 accepted groups; independent closure review pending |
+| Historical CV/document/PDF | Accepted source/fixture-bound evidence retained; affected document contracts freshly checked | No fresh physical/PDF visual metric acceptance; unchanged metrics must not be reopened without affected change |
+| Complete suites/browser contracts | Historical evidence remains source-bound | No fresh full-suite result in this cleanup branch; reviewer must reconcile required acceptance scope explicitly |
+| MariaDB/migration rollback/restore | Existing qualifications remain scoped | Current independent environment and recovery qualification incomplete; no database migration added or executed |
+| Sidecar/security/accessibility/hosted CI | Existing limited evidence retained | Full independent audit, actual plugin scans, integrated qualification, hosted/human/device gates remain open |
+
+## Decisions
+
+- CLEAN-20 implementation: locally validated and published; no further code cleanup proposed.
+- Phase 10 completion: OPEN; full acceptance is not established by targeted counts or this report.
+- Redesign completion and post-redesign Product Review acceptance: OPEN; new full-application design also requires final owner approval.
+- Independent product/research/i18n/security offline work: may continue under the owner's direct parallel-work authorisation. Do not claim upstream acceptance or integrated release qualification for isolated branches.
+- Production release: NO-GO. No merge or deployment authorised.
+
+Next: reconcile complete accepted suite evidence and remaining preservation-group qualifications, complete independent audit coverage, and record genuine reviewer/owner decisions. Keep active-host, provider, model, migration and paid-scan gates distinct from ordinary source review. Do not rerun thousands of unchanged tests solely as a restart demonstration. If a relevant implementation changes, refresh its affected checks and final integrated qualification accordingly.