docs(phase10): complete historical evidence applicability review

2026-11-10 23:17:52 +01:00
parent aa9b5468bd
commit 77982e71a5
3 changed files with 22 additions and 2 deletions
@@ -6,6 +6,7 @@
 - Passed 39 selected frontend tests, full lint and export with TypeScript. The controlled matrix passed 36 journeys and 108 axe scans/captures across nine widths, EN/NB and both themes. Zero console errors, unavailable reads or writes. The pilot overlaps the matrix. Earlier failed assertions/overflow logs remain with the final evidence. Export, source, harness and evidence integrity passed 1,696 checks.
 - Review `docs/ui-modernisation/visual-correction/APPLICATION_ACTIONS_REVIEW.md` and the 36-family route viewer in the A3 worktree. Server-backed table-density cases were discovered, with execution pending. Native devices, final visual/Gate F acceptance and live operations remain open.
 - PERF-01-RULES is source-confirmed. Settings writes can leave Jobs decisions using the old 30-second cache. A bounded isolated regression/fix is underway, including owner/global fallback and concurrency implications. No performance gain is claimed.
+- A second independent Phase 10 reviewer completed the remaining provider/sidecar/output applicability investigation at frozen `aa9b5468`. The only product delta remains App.css. Historical MariaDB, offline Python/Docling and approved PDF evidence remains applicable within its original scope. [P10-05](../redesign/phase-10/P10-05.md) records artifacts, hashes and remaining browser/preservation, human/device, current recovery, hosted and integrated security gates. Final acceptance remains open.

 ## Jobs integration and throttled comparison

@@ -8,7 +8,7 @@ Updated 10 November 2026. This is the cross-phase work list. The source prompts,
 - [x] **P10-01** Remove the approved unimported `App.css` under CLEAN-20 and publish its targeted verification. Any additional removal needs its own evidence and approval.
 - [x] **P10-02/03** Review compatibility and backend/configuration retention. Keep legacy/frozen documents, import/export, renderers, old links, migrations and SQLite where still required.
 - [ ] **P10-04** Finish applicable data and document integrity, historical CV/letter revision compatibility, MariaDB and migration/recovery evidence. **Partial**. Keep SQLite retirement separate.
- [ ] **P10-05** Independent source/evidence review matched 34 routes, 57 preservation groups, and native receipts for 1,448 backend and 1,031 frontend cases. Complete browser contract, human/device, sidecar/security and environment applicability and qualification. Reuse accepted PDF evidence for unchanged inputs.
+- [ ] **P10-05** Independent source/evidence review matched 34 routes, 57 preservation groups, and native receipts for 1,448 backend and 1,031 frontend cases. Provider/sidecar/approved PDF historical applicability review is complete for unchanged CLEAN-20 inputs. Finish browser/preservation closure, human/device, current recovery, hosted and integrated security qualification.
 - [ ] Record Phase 10, redesign development and Product Review readiness decisions with the post-redesign handoff. Track production separately. See [P10-05](../redesign/phase-10/P10-05.md).

 ## PRODUCT-REVIEW-01 · Independent product review