From b4e5fea2e5c63f365b9c986d31dfef9eb84fc0ee Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: cesnimda Date: Wed, 18 Nov 2026 19:36:14 +0100 Subject: [PATCH] docs: record full design reassessment and preserved gates --- .../DESIGN_REASSESSMENT_DIRECTIVE.md | 518 ++++++++++++++++++ docs/direct-roadmap/LATEST_CHECKPOINT.md | 7 + docs/direct-roadmap/ROADMAP_STATUS.md | 7 + docs/direct-roadmap/ROADMAP_TODO.md | 8 + 4 files changed, 540 insertions(+) create mode 100644 docs/direct-roadmap/DESIGN_REASSESSMENT_DIRECTIVE.md diff --git a/docs/direct-roadmap/DESIGN_REASSESSMENT_DIRECTIVE.md b/docs/direct-roadmap/DESIGN_REASSESSMENT_DIRECTIVE.md new file mode 100644 index 00000000..d56abc0e --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/direct-roadmap/DESIGN_REASSESSMENT_DIRECTIVE.md @@ -0,0 +1,518 @@ +# Jobjakt — FULL DESIGN REASSESSMENT + CONTINUOUS ROADMAP DEVELOPMENT + +## Owner direction + +I want to reassess the entire Jobjakt design. + +Although significant A3 implementation work has been completed, I am not entirely happy with the result. + +**I am now open to completely redesigning Jobjakt from the ground up.** + +I mean a genuinely new UI/UX direction, not another incremental restyling of the current application. + +However, I also want you to continue working on EVERYTHING ELSE in my existing roadmap concurrently wherever safe. + +Do not freeze the wider development backlog while we explore the design. + +There are three parallel objectives: + +A. Independently establish whether the existing A3 redesign is actually complete. + +B. Explore a completely fresh Jobjakt experience, with no commitment to retaining A3's visual design or information architecture. + +C. Continue implementing every other independently authorised roadmap task. + +--- + +# PART A — Verify A3 completion + +First, inspect the actual repository, worktrees, commits, application and authoritative records. + +Latest reported checkpoints: + +- Application: `2c5d0451` +- Roadmap: `8d17e01c` + +Verify the true current state. + +Read: + +- `docs/direct-roadmap/ROADMAP_TODO.md` +- `docs/direct-roadmap/ROADMAP_STATUS.md` +- `docs/direct-roadmap/LATEST_CHECKPOINT.md` +- A3 design handoff and implementation records. +- IM01–IM10 acceptance evidence. +- Applicable Phase 10 and preservation requirements. + +Audit all 34 routes and 57 preservation groups. + +Determine: + +- Which redesign milestones are implemented. +- Which are properly tested. +- Which have owner approval. +- Which are incomplete. +- Which have outstanding visual discrepancies. +- Which are awaiting real backend, mobile, accessibility or security qualification. +- Whether any old design patterns remain. + +Capture current real application screenshots at desktop, tablet and mobile widths. + +Check English, Norwegian, light and dark modes. + +Do not declare the redesign complete merely because components were migrated or tests passed. + +Produce a clear conclusion: + +- COMPLETE AND ACCEPTED. +- IMPLEMENTED BUT AWAITING ACCEPTANCE. +- PARTIALLY IMPLEMENTED. +- INCOMPLETE. + +Explain the result with evidence. + +The owner has not granted final A3 visual acceptance. + +Do not silently close that gate. + +Also reconcile the recovered CV journey proposal whose baseline still requires verification. + +--- + +# PART B — Complete UX rethink from scratch + +## 1. Start with a blank design canvas + +I am explicitly releasing the design exploration from previous A3 visual constraints. + +You may fundamentally rethink: + +- Visual identity. +- Colour system. +- Typography. +- Navigation. +- Page structure. +- Information architecture. +- Dashboard. +- Application tracking. +- Job discovery. +- CV Builder. +- Career Profile. +- Cover letters. +- Calendar. +- Correspondence. +- Onboarding. +- Settings. +- Mobile navigation. +- Desktop workflows. +- Admin interface. +- Shared design system. + +Do not simply rearrange the existing cards. + +Do not assume A3's sidebar, dashboard layout, editor position or existing interaction patterns must survive. + +Evaluate them on their merits. + +**The new interface should feel like an entirely new product.** + +However, preserve the underlying application functionality and data integrity. + +A new UI does not automatically require rewriting the backend, authentication system, database or other stable infrastructure. + +Assess whether frontend architectural replacement is justified rather than assuming it is. + +## 2. Research modern UX + +Research successful contemporary SaaS products, job-search platforms, productivity applications, career tools and CV builders. + +Examples worth examining include FlowCV, Linear, Notion, Teal and Huntr, alongside other relevant products. + +Assess actual current interfaces rather than assuming past designs remain unchanged. + +Study: + +- Navigation simplicity. +- Information density. +- Visual hierarchy. +- Form usability. +- Responsive behaviour. +- Search and filtering. +- Progressive disclosure. +- Onboarding. +- Document editing. +- Status and workflow management. +- Accessibility. +- Perceived performance. + +Identify patterns worth adopting. + +Avoid copying another product's branding, assets or complete design. + +## 3. Design for every jobseeker + +Jobjakt is not a software-developer-only application. + +It must work intuitively for people seeking work in: + +- Technology. +- Healthcare. +- Education. +- Retail. +- Hospitality. +- Construction. +- Engineering. +- Administration. +- Public services. +- Skilled trades. +- And other occupations. + +It must support beginners and experienced users. + +Avoid interfaces that look like internal enterprise administration software. + +Everyday users should understand important actions without technical knowledge. + +Keep advanced features accessible without displaying every control at once. + +## 4. European-first architecture + +This remains non-negotiable. + +Support the existing European expansion requirements: + +- All 24 official EU languages. +- The approved additional European languages. +- Country-aware job searching. +- Accurate country-specific maps. +- Canonical geographic filtering. +- International occupations. +- Correct regional conventions. +- Multilingual documents. +- Independent UI, search and document language settings. + +Design for longer translations and different writing systems from the beginning. + +Do not design English-only screens and treat localisation as an afterthought. + +## 5. Explore five genuinely distinct directions + +Produce FIVE different high-fidelity design concepts. + +They must differ meaningfully in: + +- Information architecture. +- Navigation. +- Workspace organisation. +- Visual design. +- Density. +- Interaction patterns. +- Desktop and mobile behaviour. + +Suggested starting points: + +**Concept A — Minimal Productivity Workspace** +Fast, clean, understated, excellent information density. + +**Concept B — Friendly Career Workspace** +Approachable, guided, welcoming and easy for beginners. + +**Concept C — Career and Document Studio** +Strong focus on creating CVs, building profiles and preparing applications. + +**Concept D — Premium Career Platform** +Distinctive branding, sophisticated interaction and polished consumer-product quality. + +**Concept E — Your Own Recommendation** +An original direction based on the strongest research and an independent assessment of Jobjakt. + +Do not produce five versions of the same layout with different colours. + +Do not constrain the concepts to A3. + +## 6. Show complete user experiences + +For every concept, include representative desktop and mobile screens: + +- Dashboard. +- Job discovery. +- Application list. +- Application details. +- Career Profile. +- CV Builder. +- Cover letters. +- Calendar. +- Correspondence. +- Settings. +- Administration. +- First-time onboarding. + +Use realistic synthetic content. + +Show actual density, states, controls and workflows. + +Include light and dark themes. + +Demonstrate how layouts adapt to mobile rather than simply shrinking desktop. + +Explore how users move through complete journeys, including: + +Discover job → inspect → save → apply → track → follow up. + +Career Profile → prepare CV → review → export. + +Interview invitation → calendar → preparation → follow-up. + +## 7. Create working prototypes + +Produce real, clickable browser prototypes where feasible. + +I want to experience the different approaches, not merely read design descriptions. + +Provide: + +- A concept gallery. +- Desktop previews. +- Mobile previews. +- Interactive navigation. +- Representative editing interactions. +- Light/dark switching. +- English/Norwegian previews. +- Screenshots. +- A comparison of strengths, weaknesses and tradeoffs. + +Use the approved development environment and synthetic data. + +Do not deploy these prototypes to production. + +If external inspiration or imagery is used, respect usage rights and attribution. + +## 8. Challenge existing design decisions + +Do not assume the current navigation is best. + +Consider whether Jobjakt really needs its existing number of navigation destinations. + +Explore grouping functionality into intuitive areas such as: + +- Home. +- Explore. +- Applications. +- Career. +- Calendar. +- Account. + +These are illustrative, not mandatory. + +Think about whether jobs, correspondence, documents, interviews and follow-ups should be connected within one application workspace instead of spread across unrelated pages. + +Look for opportunities to reduce the number of clicks needed to complete everyday tasks. + +Keep advanced features discoverable. + +Avoid excessive boxes inside boxes. + +Use typography, spacing and purposeful layout divisions rather than decorative cards everywhere. + +Do not mistake minimalism for hiding functionality. + +## 9. Evaluate implementation strategies + +Compare at least: + +A. Thorough redesign using the existing React/component architecture. + +B. Major frontend restructuring with new shared architecture and components. + +C. A fresh frontend implementation built around the existing backend APIs. + +Assess: + +- Expected design freedom. +- Risk to preserved functionality. +- Development effort. +- Testing and migration cost. +- Accessibility. +- Performance. +- Maintainability. +- European localisation. +- Compatibility with current workstreams. + +Recommend the best approach with evidence. + +Do not automatically choose the most expensive rewrite. + +Do not begin replacing the production frontend without owner approval. + +## 10. Owner design review + +Once the five concepts and comparison are ready, present them for review. + +I want to be able to: + +- Choose a preferred concept. +- Combine features from different concepts. +- Reject individual visual patterns. +- Request changes. +- Continue iterating until I am satisfied. + +Do not assume I will choose the first recommended design. + +Do not begin full replacement implementation until I explicitly approve the selected direction and implementation strategy. + +While waiting for design feedback, continue independently authorised work elsewhere in the roadmap. + +--- + +# PART C — Continue everything else + +This is equally important. + +**The new design exploration must NOT stop the rest of Jobjakt development.** + +Continue the previously approved maximum-backlog execution directive. + +Work through the entire existing TODO, including: + +- Phase 10 eligible acceptance and integrity work. +- Product Review preparation. +- International Global Job Search. +- European localisation. +- EUROPE-READY geographic support. +- All applicable performance optimisations. +- Public homepage work within approved scope. +- Security and dependency remediation. +- Release readiness. +- Database and operational improvements. +- Existing technical debt. +- Outstanding functional and integration defects. + +Respect existing gates. + +Do not use the potential redesign as an excuse to abandon substantial previously completed work. + +## Parallel execution + +Where Codex supports safe parallel workers, establish independent ownership. + +Suggested workstreams: + +**Worker A — Existing A3 audit** +Establish actual completion and preservation status. + +**Worker B — From-scratch UX research and concepts** +Produce new design options and prototypes without modifying live application behaviour. + +**Worker C — European expansion** +Continue localisation, geographical architecture and independently authorised Global Jobs work. + +**Worker D — Backend, security and performance** +Continue validated backend optimisations, dependency remediation, data integrity and operational improvements. + +Use actual worker availability and reasonable hardware limits. + +Run fewer workers if necessary. + +Workers must not collide on shared files or mutable databases. + +Assign separate branches/worktrees where appropriate. + +## Avoid wasted implementation + +Since we may replace the visual design completely, deprioritise discretionary cosmetic polishing of existing A3 components. + +Still fix: + +- Security vulnerabilities. +- Data loss. +- Incorrect functionality. +- Accessibility failures. +- User-isolation problems. +- High-impact defects. + +Continue implementation of reusable business logic, APIs, localisation infrastructure, data models, tests and other design-independent work. + +Do not remove accepted functionality because its existing presentation might be replaced. + +## Continuous progress + +After every validated implementation package: + +1. Update the authoritative TODO. +2. Record tests and evidence. +3. Commit and publish when authorised. +4. Select the next independently eligible backlog task. +5. Continue immediately. + +Do not stop merely to deliver small milestone summaries. + +Maintain separate statuses for: + +- Existing A3 completion. +- New redesign research. +- New redesign owner approval. +- New redesign implementation. +- Wider roadmap implementation. +- Final product acceptance. + +Do not falsely mark the proposed redesign as implemented. + +## Approval and safety boundaries + +Maintain all existing restrictions: + +- No autonomous orchestrator. +- No merge into main. +- No production deployment. +- No destructive migrations. +- No unapproved third-party costs. +- No bypassing mandatory owner decisions. +- No unqualified production AI/provider activation. +- No removal of protected historical data or functionality. +- No claims of acceptance without evidence. + +Use prior verified test evidence where still applicable. + +Batch owner decisions where possible. + +However, the new design selection is an explicit mandatory owner gate. + +Do not self-approve it. + +## Required deliverables + +### A3 assessment +A factual report explaining whether the existing redesign is complete, partial or awaiting acceptance. + +### New design exploration +Five distinct interactive visual concepts with desktop/mobile coverage, screenshots and a comparative recommendation. + +### Implementation recommendation +A reasoned comparison of updating, restructuring or replacing the frontend. + +### Preservation analysis +Evidence showing how all current functionality and routes can survive a new design. + +### Roadmap progress +Completed implementation, test results, commits, published changes, blockers and remaining authorised tasks. + +### Owner decisions +A consolidated design-review package plus any other genuinely blocked decisions. + +## Final directive + +Begin immediately. + +**Assess A3, explore a completely new Jobjakt design, and keep developing the remaining roadmap concurrently wherever safely possible.** + +I am open to starting the user experience over from the ground up. + +Do not restrict the exploration to the old A3 design. + +Do not discard existing application functionality. + +Do not pause other independent development work while design choices await my review. + +Make substantial progress for as long as the execution environment permits. + +The objective is to build the best possible Jobjakt experience for European jobseekers, not simply finish the existing design checklist. \ No newline at end of file diff --git a/docs/direct-roadmap/LATEST_CHECKPOINT.md b/docs/direct-roadmap/LATEST_CHECKPOINT.md index 03e0c506..ec2bf0f1 100644 --- a/docs/direct-roadmap/LATEST_CHECKPOINT.md +++ b/docs/direct-roadmap/LATEST_CHECKPOINT.md @@ -1,5 +1,12 @@ # Direct execution continuation +## Full design reassessment authorised + +Owner directive archived in DESIGN_REASSESSMENT_DIRECTIVE.md; SHA256 5b7fc4f837569f01286ba57fa07954d6fafae716611a3898387c595314a72de5. Exploration is released from A3 visual/navigation constraints. Five NEW distinct clickable concepts are requested; preserve original A3 prototypes and all functionality. No replacement implementation until explicit selected-direction AND strategy approval. A3 final visual acceptance remains absent. Separate statuses: existing A3 audit ACTIVE; new research/prototypes PENDING; new owner approval PENDING; replacement implementation NOT AUTHORISED; wider roadmap CONTINUES. All24 EU/all60 planned locale scope retained. Deprioritise discretionary A3 cosmetics; continue integrity/accessibility/business logic/performance and other eligible work. + +Read-only/report worker design_reassessment_audit dispatched for34routes/57groups and IM01–10; owns only docs/ui-modernisation/reassessment/A3_ASSESSMENT.md. Second research worker creation failed at agent thread limit; no research/prototype work claimed. Root must perform research/prototypes sequentially or reuse an available worker without idle retries. Next: reconcile CV proposal baseline, inspect current official product interfaces, build five new concepts in an isolated design lab, capture real application desktop/tablet/mobile EN/NB light/dark separately. Existing checkpoint8d17e01c and A3 reported2c5d0451 remain baseline pending fresh audit. + + ## Recovery audit continuation Roadmap encoding repair798c410e published/refverified; verified c18c69f8 historical checkpoint/status preserved verbatim with legitimate new entries.36 non-orchestrator worktrees inspected; snapshot retained at E:/Storage/Projects/Active/temp docs/jobjakt-local-build/browser-restoration-20261117/recovery-worktrees.json. Main checkout unrelated dirty files untouched. A3 remote2c5d0451 and performance remote2a212c78 verified. diff --git a/docs/direct-roadmap/ROADMAP_STATUS.md b/docs/direct-roadmap/ROADMAP_STATUS.md index d91b4d9c..e8b6a51f 100644 --- a/docs/direct-roadmap/ROADMAP_STATUS.md +++ b/docs/direct-roadmap/ROADMAP_STATUS.md @@ -1,5 +1,12 @@ # Direct roadmap status +## Full design reassessment authorised + +Owner directive archived in DESIGN_REASSESSMENT_DIRECTIVE.md; SHA256 5b7fc4f837569f01286ba57fa07954d6fafae716611a3898387c595314a72de5. Exploration is released from A3 visual/navigation constraints. Five NEW distinct clickable concepts are requested; preserve original A3 prototypes and all functionality. No replacement implementation until explicit selected-direction AND strategy approval. A3 final visual acceptance remains absent. Separate statuses: existing A3 audit ACTIVE; new research/prototypes PENDING; new owner approval PENDING; replacement implementation NOT AUTHORISED; wider roadmap CONTINUES. All24 EU/all60 planned locale scope retained. Deprioritise discretionary A3 cosmetics; continue integrity/accessibility/business logic/performance and other eligible work. + +Read-only/report worker design_reassessment_audit dispatched for34routes/57groups and IM01–10; owns only docs/ui-modernisation/reassessment/A3_ASSESSMENT.md. Second research worker creation failed at agent thread limit; no research/prototype work claimed. Root must perform research/prototypes sequentially or reuse an available worker without idle retries. Next: reconcile CV proposal baseline, inspect current official product interfaces, build five new concepts in an isolated design lab, capture real application desktop/tablet/mobile EN/NB light/dark separately. Existing checkpoint8d17e01c and A3 reported2c5d0451 remain baseline pending fresh audit. + + ## 18 November combined journeys and user-summary projection published A3 `2c5d04513eb02a9b3771fde5c27ea3e378fc5d92` published/ref-readback verified. Combined browser evidence171e616b integrated213793c1: fresh Release API on combined checklist/analytics source plus unchanged qualified export;4/4 connected discovery/calendar cases,8scans/8screenshots,0violations,0skips/flaky. Prior distinct-case counts overlap; no full/native-language/visual acceptance. diff --git a/docs/direct-roadmap/ROADMAP_TODO.md b/docs/direct-roadmap/ROADMAP_TODO.md index bcdb4eba..d4b1d4fb 100644 --- a/docs/direct-roadmap/ROADMAP_TODO.md +++ b/docs/direct-roadmap/ROADMAP_TODO.md @@ -278,3 +278,11 @@ Next integrity investigation:AttachmentStorage snapshot cleanup ownership (sourc - [x] **Combined connected backend/browser qualification**.171e616b integrated213793c1, published/refverified;4cases/8scans/8captures pass on fresh combined API with unchanged export. Earlier cases overlap; broader/native-language/visual acceptance remains open. - [x] **User-list summary SQL projection**.2a212c78 integrated2c5d0451, published/refverified;49to10 selected columns,12 affected ordinary cases+2 actual MariaDB safety fixtures pass,AST/source/native receipts committed. Full Users paging remains open. + +## Full design reassessment (new owner direction) + +- [ ] Independently audit A3:34routes/57groups,IM01–10 evidence,owner gates,current rendered desktop/tablet/mobile EN/NB light/dark; no final acceptance inferred. +- [ ] Research current public interfaces and create five distinct clickable concepts covering all12 requested screen families and connected journeys. Preserve original prototypes. +- [ ] Compare existing-component redesign,major frontend restructure,and new API-backed frontend; preserve functionality/data/routes. +- [ ] Present consolidated concept/strategy review; explicit owner approval required before replacement implementation. +- [ ] Continue wider authorised roadmap and recovered CV journey while design exploration proceeds.