cesnimda
3.4 KiB
Independent source review
Reviewer: separate AI code-review agent. Baseline3727a72 through published e80815f and the subsequent working-tree focus/fixture delta. This is source review, not human acceptance or runtime approval. The reviewer ran no tests, builds, browsers, databases or service commands.
The review covered the shared document-font renderer, resource/publish configuration, original font/license bytes, Python dependency and advisory inventory, CI isolation documentation, and connected persistence/normalization owners. No Critical or Important application-code finding was reported. Canonical data, revisions, settings/null inheritance and frozen artifact writers remain at their established owners.
Two evidence findings were resolved: an uncommitted experimental collector did not retain exact eight-state settings membership, so it and its test were deleted and the existing collector/oracle reused unchanged; two license entries and some per-file sources were absent from font provenance, so the manifest was completed. The reviewer verified all37 font/license source/hash entries and confirmed no bundled assets were omitted. The whitespace exception is limited to byte-preserved upstream notices.
The reviewer verified all109 advisory rows contain the required fields and the exact current lock hash matches the inventory:65 groups remediated,44 retained (three cache-lock and41 model-runtime groups). No owner risk acceptance is inferred. CI changes remain documentation only.
The final delta review found no Critical or Important finding in the preview focus guard or fixture changes. Descendant controls retain their pointer positions; mobile-pane selection remains and direct preview-region focus still scrolls its pane. The native regression now holds pointer-down through layout frames. The stale-draft fixture observes real autosave409/200 responses while retaining its draft/download/version/history assertions.
Runtime proof is owned by the qualification ledger. Source review does not certify PDF fidelity, full model inference, hosted isolation, accessibility compliance, physical printing or production readiness.
Supplemental evidence review — 25 October
Independent read-only review of the new qualification wrappers, representative producers and reconciliation found an Important acceptance gap: a stale supplemental PDF result could pass without exact membership or pre-oracle input binding. The producer now records every input hash before the unchanged oracle, verifies inputs afterward and records the report hash. Reconciliation requires this existing manifest, exact two-fixture membership and successful report/case equality, required artifacts, original oracle identity and current input/report hashes. Follow-up independent review found no remaining Critical/Important issue in that delta. Eight offline collector checks pass; these are evidence-accounting checks, not additional application/browser/PDF execution. The owned waiting helper was restarted before the supplemental lane began; its source transition is retained in raw restart receipts.
Final narrative review limit
The additional independent final-document consistency pass could not run because the reviewer reached its usage limit. Earlier independent application and evidence-helper reviews completed, including closure of the Important pre/post oracle binding finding. Final narrative, counts, links and hashes were checked by the primary agent; no independent final narrative approval is claimed.