cesnimda
1.6 KiB
Task 1 independent source review
Reviewed the working Career backend patch against 8f2cad6, REQUEST.md and PLAN Task 1. No actionable correctness/security finding identified in the reviewed change.
Scope: CareerProfileService, CareerProfileController, ProfileCvController parse/diff/accept and pipeline changes, CareerProfile.Version concurrency configuration in JobTrackerContext, Rd21CareerPersistenceTests and associated caller/fixture changes. No product edits or test/server/network runs performed for this review.
Checks included the eventual EF revision comparison, missing/stale preconditions, first-save owner-unique translation, controller-owned transaction scope across canonical row/children/history/Identity/import metadata, failure rollback and tracker clearing, read-only coherent relational snapshot/raw-text reads, restore behavior, unchanged tenant filters and public owner-specific read behavior. The four production canonical replacement callers use explicit expected revisions; no blind-save overload was introduced.
Evidence boundary: test source and the worker's report were inspected; their executions were not independently repeated. The first-save SQLite test starts competing requests after both editors read revision zero; it does not independently exercise the MySQL duplicate-index error branch. Actual MariaDB transaction/constraint qualification, full backend regression and frontend/browser acknowledgement/retention remain coordinator-owned. The worker report explicitly preserves these qualifications and marks its newest revision-zero raw-text case pending the next coordinator run.