cesnimda
10 KiB
P10-ENTRY-FINAL acceptance and handoff
Safely actionable PDF work implemented; evidence package READY. Phase10 development NO-GO, automatic execution false, production NO-GO. No protected owner decision is supplied by this report.
Branch test/pre-phase10-ux-acceptance, starting accepted package26d531cc9079be3be7601f42cb101035de022a4d. Application correction154a9e89f565e786d7df00bf93d873da900a7c7d; diagnostic checkpoints4024a89/38d7133; handoff source guard52fb91e. Final exact published candidate and independently resolved envelope are specified by ENTRY_PROPOSAL.json and ACCEPTANCE.json. These later source snapshots preserve all tested application/diagnostic bytes. Existing CV-UX4a0af62 ancestry is retained. No main merge, deployment, model/cache operation, separate-controller mutation or Phase10 implementation occurred.
The mission is complete within its evidence-only authority. The remaining PDF metric decision, human checks and protected entry/runtime/scope actions require the real owner/operator; they cannot be completed by assigning a model-written GO.
Findings and smallest correction
All48 original revised S01 failures have a specific verified explanation, with all72 passing/failing controls listed in S01_CLASSIFICATION.csv and exact native hashes in S01_CLASSIFICATION.json. The old test compares a DOM Range top with a PDF extractor's descent-derived one-em cell top, rather than like-for-like geometry. Actual native text matrices, an inline DOM baseline sentinel, independent canvas ascent and bounded SFNT tables reproduce the difference. The cell formula residual is below0.01px. Every failed case is INCORRECT_TEST_ASSUMPTION with native font-descriptor metadata as a secondary cause. The Windows-only technical/nordic failures account for the platform count difference. No failure was silently waived.
After the correction, unchanged original S01 results remain Windows8/36PASS,28FAIL; Linux16/36PASS,20FAIL. Actual baseline deltas are at most 0.227378mm Windows /0.367938mm Linux against the same2mm bound; actual S01 ink differences are at most2px/2px. This is a supplementary diagnostic, not an approved replacement gate. No golden, font, original oracle or tolerance changed. The candidate metric requires an explicit owner reference/criterion disposition. Windows native/preview Chromium151 and Linux native156/preview151 differ in both OS and release; selection cannot be attributed exclusively to OS without a matched-version experiment.
A separate real defect was found: full names could paint accents above the first print fragment even when preview and PDF agreed. The new regression failed24/36 derived CV variants and2/18 letter variants before the fix. Shared revised CV names and letter sender headings now receive2mm top padding, preserving their existing leading. Actual API/native assertions were RED then GREEN; all derived36CV/18letter clearance variants and actual9CV+9letter European-name controls pass per platform. Version1 markup is unchanged; existing stored/historical revisions are not rewritten. Photo-free themes remain intentionally photo-free. DIAGNOSIS.md retains the full investigation and distinguishes superseded line-height experiments from the implemented padding correction.
Fresh validation after the application correction
| Lane | Outcome and scope |
|---|---|
| Backend | 1448PASS,0fail/skip |
| Frontend | 1031PASS/112suites,0fail/pending |
| Affected Windows browser | 51PASS: focused2 plus disjoint49, exact discovery membership;0unexpected/flaky/skips/retries |
| Additional browser lanes | PDF admission1, RD216, real import8(3+4+1), real MariaDB3(1+2), native Linux8PASS; separately scoped, not added to the51 |
| MariaDB provider | 90PASS; transaction/concurrency/rollback/recovery checks; exact owned test cleanup |
| Python | 83offline+14real DoclingPASS; model loading disabled; no new inference |
| Baseline diagnostic tests | 5PASS; reject actual shifts beyond2mm and wrong metric/sign/unit correspondence |
| TypeScript/lint/build | TypeScript, lint, frontend/API build, isolated Linux image, Windows launcher restoration exit0 |
| Original PDFs, each platform | 24CV/60pages and4letters/14pagesPASS |
| Revised PDFs, each platform | 36CV/122pages content/bounds/name wrapping/inkPASS; full-height sidebars43/43PASS; matching18letters/38pagesPASS |
| Additional actual native controls, each platform | 9no-photo European-name CVs/9pages +9European-name letters/9pagesPASS; real API exports, semantic/bounds/page checks |
| Revised original S01 gate | FAIL28Windows/20Linux, retained unchanged |
| Handoff tests | Final combined19 source/parser/schema/authority/tampering tests; bootstrap7 and old18 are overlapping, never additive. See current indexed native report |
Raw command exits, native membership, before/after source hashes, exact image/DLL/runtime and cleanup are in TEST_EVIDENCE.json. Frozen application/diagnostic bytes are154a9e8; the focused2 executed the exact later-committed dirty38d7133 bytes, proved by indexed fingerprints. Later runs are at154a9e8 or documentation-only52fb91e. Documentation-envelope binding is not a claim that tests executed at a future commit.
The preceding accepted380-case broad ordinary suite,53 specialized checks and independent helpers are historical5032ccb evidence, preserved in Git26d531c and the indexed old manifest; they were not rerun as current380. The current task reran all1448backend/1031frontend tests and the affected51 browser cases plus the listed separate lanes. No old run or repeated native measurement is added to new totals. No new whole-repository security scan, model semantic benchmark, hosted CI, production or human acceptance is claimed.
Native owner review
Review guide links eight bounded ZIPs and navigation sheets containing 326 byte-preserved PDF archive entries:200fresh after-fix documents,108actual before-fix documents,18clearly historical version1 reference entries (the same nine-theme historical files included in both platform bundles). Both platforms include original/revised, short/long/dense/multipage, Bokmål/European diacritics, photo/no-photo, all nine themes, sidebars and matching letters. PDF source/archive SHA256 correspondences are retained. Preview/native before/after name crops aid inspection; JPEGs are navigation only, never goldens or human approval.
The normal local development backend still reports caa0c6a2efea5a6e9d8910f55fb00fd982cd48fd; it was not replaced. Review candidate PDFs immediately, or use an isolated build of the published candidate for interactive confirmation. Do not mistake that earlier runtime for the candidate fix.
Failures, recovery and limitations
- New assertions failed before the correction; the first GREEN attempt also caught an incorrect new photo expectation for themes whose DTO explicitly says none. It was corrected using the existing template contract, with no product/theme behavior weakened.
- The first post-fix import lane ran concurrently with Linux publish, which removed the Windows apphost; it stopped before cases executed. Owned parser resources were removed. The recovered serial lane restores the apphost before a fresh import/MariaDB run. Original logs/cleanup remain indexed; the failed attempt contributes0passing cases.
- An optional direct native legacy-control CLI timed out before any document completed. Exact root process/profile ownership was checked, its process tree terminated, absence confirmed and its exact temp profile removed. This attempt is not a successful product qualification. Fresh original28/platform plus existing36version1 markup/CSS compatibility tests remain the current compatibility evidence; nine extra native v1 references are labelled historical.
- Human visual/device/AT/copy/physical print acceptance remains NOT TESTED. Revised S01 gate remains FAIL pending explicit owner metric disposition. The finite automated clipping fix does not approve general typography or printing.
- Existing three CV-model probes remain rejected historical evidence; no new inference was run. CV adapter remains disabled; no source-grounded AI accuracy PASS. Dependency/advisory history is carried separately with no new risk waiver: Python vendor Torch404 incomplete, full frontend5low/production0, MySqlConnector moderate, hosted/native-image/operator concerns unchanged.
Independent entry and release decisions
Actual accent clipping: PASS_AUTOMATED_FINITE_CORPUS. Original PDF compatibility: PASS. Deterministic baseline diagnostic: PASS_DIAGNOSTIC_ONLY. Revised unchanged automated fidelity: FAIL. PDF spacing: PARTIAL. Human/printing: NOT TESTED. CV AI: BLOCKED. Package integrity: independently verified separately from entry. Phase10: NO-GO. Automatic execution: false. Production: NO-GO.
Required owner actions are concrete in OWNER_REVIEW.md. First inspect/disposition the revised S01 metric and actual rendered samples; then independently approve the exact published baseline and a proven candidate or assessment-only scope, and qualify the separate real runtime/key/sign-in/composite adapter/policy. No deletion candidate has been proved unused and none is approved. Five conditional-development debt requests retain their source-specific authority; none is granted or executable here, and all controller checkpoint deferrableGates remain empty. Production-only backup/filesystem/recovery/TLS/native-image/manual/provider matters remain independent blockers.
The separate committed controller140e182 remains only an external read-only snapshot:69Python(includes48)+6signature and native MXC canaries are its history, not our tests. Real owner key/sign-in/adapter/activation remain unqualified. No queue, signed approval, policy or other worktree was modified. All57preservation criteria and34routes remain56PARTIAL/1DEFERRED. No cleanup, Product Review, Global Jobs, Phase10 or other initiative was started.