cesnimda/jobtrackingapp
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Actions 2 Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity

docs(phase10): complete direct P10-00 assessment

Browse Source
This commit is contained in:
cesnimda
2026-11-02 01:00:58 +01:00
parent fc5b9d3771
commit 7ba1367fd2
4 changed files with 258 additions and 0 deletions
Download Patch File Download Diff File Expand all files Collapse all files
docs/automation/stages/PHASE-10/P10-00.md
+95
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,95 @@
# P10-00 — Baseline and deletion eligibility assessment
> **Direct-chat review, 2 November 2026:** this draft is preserved below as historical worker evidence. The completed direct assessment is [P10-00](../../../redesign/phase-10/P10-00.md), with [continuity and the next gate](../../../redesign/phase-10/HANDOFF.md). Its current Git observations, evidence checks and narrowly nominated `App.css` candidate supersede this draft's unavailable-Git and no-candidate conclusions. Controller-specific claims below are historical, not verified authority in this chat. The owner authorised direct P10-00 assessment only; the orchestrator remains paused and untouched. No P10-01 implementation is authorised.
Date: 1 November 2026. Scope: read-only assessment and this Markdown report only.
## Decision and authority
P10-00 worker handoff is ready for independent controller checks. This is not checkpoint acceptance or full Phase 10 completion. No deletion is eligible on the evidence inspected. Recommend no P10-01 implementation scope at present. Stop at the protected `candidate-specific-cleanup-scope` gate.
The active checkpoint and supplied verified owner decisions supersede the older handoff's unconfigured-adapter/unsigned-entry statements only for this restricted assessment. They authorize inspection and Markdown reporting at proposed integration baseline `fc5b9d377199ce51f480a920a3772108094929e3`; they do not authorize product changes, later checkpoints, security waivers or production. Active manifest identity supplied by the controller is `51e12f29078c420ac4ebd10127c8b7f7ba3cd73eac09dcbb4d47da1fe88fbeaf`. Private receipts and credentials were not accessed.
The current control contract prohibits worker branch changes, commits and pushes. Consequently the controller must verify the current branch, clean immutable candidate, ancestry, source correspondence, normal publication and exact remote readback. No network query was made. Attempts to obtain Git identity failed because the worktree Git metadata was inaccessible. The shell started at `C:\` despite requested working directory; changing directory failed at the denied ancestor. Direct absolute-path reads of permitted repository files succeeded. This limits identity verification, not the authority of the supplied baseline. No alternate Git directory or permission bypass was used.
## Entry evidence reviewed
Read repository `AGENTS.md` and `docs/redesign/IMPLEMENTATION_PLAN.md`, especially its requirement for unused-route proof, passing tests and preserved functionality before removal. Reviewed acceptance introductions and relevant evidence sections in:
| Authority | Retained decision |
| --- | --- |
| `docs/redesign/phase-9/p9-requal-01/ACCEPTANCE_ADDENDUM_2026-10-24.md` | Historical Phase 9/10 NO-GO; RD21 resolved only in tested scope; hosted MariaDB blocked. |
| `docs/redesign/phase-9/p9-sec-02/ACCEPTANCE_ADDENDUM_2026-10-25.md` | Later Phase 9 CONDITIONAL GO for qualified development; incomplete vendor Torch advisory response and release limitations retained. |
| `docs/cv-redesign/ACCEPTANCE.md` | CV-UX-01 automated development PASS; overall CONDITIONAL GO; human/model/release limitations remain. This is the actual CV-UX report location. |
| `docs/cv-import/ACCEPTANCE.md` | CV-IMPORT-01 CONDITIONAL GO for supported model-independent workflow; optional model adapter disabled/disconnected. |
| `docs/cv-integration-qa/ACCEPTANCE.md` | CV-QA-01 CONDITIONAL GO; assessment/planning only, not cleanup authority. |
| Supplied final entry, ready-to-run, protected request, acceptance, blockers, gates and entry proposal | Frozen tested application `ba04d817fed26d659bfa2a56b089d6cac851dc34`; published proposal `fc5b9d3`; PDF visual/S01 development approval does not establish physical printing or entry authority. |
| Supplied active checkpoint and verified owner decisions | Assessment entry/evidence-reuse/runtime applicability granted; independent canaries pending; protected stop after P10-00. |
The supplied original 19-entry inventory and prior CV-QA handoffs are carried forward below, with newly inspected source observations explicitly distinguished from inherited findings. These reports are not independently rehashed native evidence in this worker turn. No old conditional decision has been promoted to unconditional acceptance.
## Candidate inventory
All entries have action **retain** unless stated otherwise. Historical purpose and current consumer are combined in the second column. An active consumer defeats a deletion proposal; it does not require proving exhaustive non-use. No entry below asserts absence of runtime consumers. Group mappings are affected groups, not new PASS claims.
| ID / file or area | Historical purpose / current consumers and evidence | Preservation / proposed tests / risk |
| --- | --- | --- |
| CLEAN-01 `src/views/CvBuilderEditor.tsx` | CV authoring owner. Directly observed `App.tsx` lazy import and `/career/builder/:id` registration; not superseded merely by new library UI. | C05–C10; blank/inherited CV, undo/history/save/recovery/browser; HIGH. |
| CLEAN-02 `src/components/CvTemplateThumbnail.tsx` | Template preview. Directly observed `CvTemplateGallery.tsx` import and render. Inherited inventory identifies sandboxed server sample HTML/cache/error paths. | C05/C08/C12; gallery/sample error/iframe/PDF checks; HIGH. |
| CLEAN-03 `src/components/CvTemplateGallery.tsx` | Selection/library with explicit Apply and entitlement semantics; thumbnail composition directly inspected, no duplicate implementation established. | C05/C08; selection/legacy design/entitlement/browser; HIGH. |
| CLEAN-04 `src/views/career/CvImportReview.tsx`, `CvImportMappingEditor.tsx` | Source correction/review owner. Directly observed `CareerProfilePage.tsx` renders review for pending/applied `docling-v1` runs; mapping responsibility inherited from CV-QA. | C01–C03; PDF/DOCX correction/assignment/duplicates/provider rollback; CRITICAL. |
| CLEAN-05 legacy `CareerProfilePage.tsx` / `ProfileCvController.cs` | Historical non-Docling review. Directly observed non-Docling diff condition, POST `/profile-cv/runs/${runId}/accept`, and `[HttpPost("runs/{id:int}/accept")]`; a paired UI/API consumer exists. | C01–C03; old-run fixtures, accept/discard/conflict/replay; CRITICAL. |
| CLEAN-06 `src/components/DashboardLayoutEditor.tsx` | Show/hide/save/reset/conflict/navigation owner. Directly observed `components/DashboardView.tsx` imports and renders both editor and grid. Grid is not its replacement. | M01–M06/E07/E08; preferences/keyboard/navigation/conflict/responsive; HIGH. |
| CLEAN-07 `src/dashboardLayout.ts`, `hooks/useDashboardLayout.ts` | Persisted layout migration/CAS and hidden/future widgets per inherited inventory; hook directly imported by DashboardView. | M01–M06/S01–S05; v1/v2 migration, stale save, account disposal; HIGH. |
| CLEAN-08 `src/views/AdminProcessingPage.tsx` | Current owner-scoped operation monitor; direct lazy import and `/admin/processing` registration in App. Audit/users/system routes remain separately registered. | A01–A03/E09/W12; authorization/redaction/rate/polling/browser; CRITICAL. |
| CLEAN-09 redirects in `src/App.tsx` | Historical bookmarks/extensions. Directly observed `/kanban`, `/correspondence/review`, `/applications/:id` use compatibility redirect elements. | E07/J04/J07/W01; query/hash/navigation/ownership contracts; HIGH. |
| CLEAN-10 `Models/CvTheme.cs`, `Services/ThemedCvRenderer.cs` | Historical document design. Directly observed version-sensitive theme resolution and multiple `DesignVersion == 2` layout branches; new appearance does not retire old settings. | C05–C12/W06/W07; unchanged Windows/Linux CV/letter goldens and frozen archives; CRITICAL. |
| CLEAN-11 `CareerProfileMapper.cs` and import mapping/interpreter owners | Canonical persistence versus source interpretation/review translation; inherited CV-QA distinguishes side effects. No duplicate owner proved. | C01–C03/W05; provider transactions/rollback/replay/stale revision; CRITICAL. |
| CLEAN-12 `ApplicationAssetsService.cs`, versioned writers | Inherited application/CV/letter/frozen submission contracts include null/no-op and RD21 behavior. No obsolete writer established. | W05–W07/C10; all writer, ownership, retry/conflict/frozen-byte tests; CRITICAL. |
| CLEAN-13 migrations/context/provider helpers | Existing installation adoption and provider compatibility; staged retirement report explicitly withholds deletion. | All groups with persistence; migration/populated startup/parity/backup-restore; CRITICAL. |
| CLEAN-14 `tools/summarizer/parser_child.py`, legacy extraction, Docling runtime | Inherited attachment/text consumers differ from structural CV conversion. Full runtime/route/image consumer census still needed. | C03/W08/W03; legacy extraction, parser security, actual Docling; HIGH. |
| CLEAN-15 `tools/summarizer/cv_import_ai.py`, `CV_IMPORT_AI_ENABLED` | Disabled optional capability with contract tests, not obsolete functionality. Retain disabled; no activation. | C11/C03; disabled transport/schema/grounding/failure tests, separate model qualification; HIGH. |
| CLEAN-16 shared styles/tokens/fonts/accessibility utilities | App theme and physical document/iframe/export styles have distinct owners; no asset/token unused proof. Dynamic names/embedding/locales remain unresolved census requirements. | E08/C08/C09/C12; type/lint/build/theme/EN/NB/axe/native PDF; HIGH. |
| CLEAN-17 package/lock dependencies | Directly inspected `package.json` runtime/test/build scripts. `DashboardGrid.tsx` imports `react-grid-layout` and its CSS. No dependency removal justified by age or dependency section. | All affected groups; runtime/tool/script/Docker/platform census, reproducible lock/build/security/provider checks; HIGH. |
| CLEAN-18 tests/goldens/historical reports | Regression and audit consumers, including original failures. Do not discard fixtures or assertions because newer paths pass. No obsolete fixture demonstrated. | All 57; discovery membership/oracle hashes/evidence integrity; HIGH. |
| CLEAN-19 shell/dashboard reminder reads | Inherited P9-PERF-01 measurement candidate only; current duplicate request count not measured. Proposed action: retain, consider separately bounded measurement before consolidation. | W11/M01–M06/E09; loading/error/refresh/account disposal and before/after network counts; MEDIUM. |
Frontend paths in this table are relative to `job-tracker-ui`; backend paths are relative to `JobTrackerApi` unless otherwise qualified. Preservation prefixes are `PRES-`.
## Census coverage and limitations
Direct source inspection covered outer/public and shell route registrations, lazy imports, paired historical import UI/API consumers, design-version branches, dashboard ownership, gallery composition and dependency scripts. This uses several independent kinds of evidence; no safety conclusion rests on a single negative search. `rg` was unavailable, so bounded PowerShell reads and searches were used. No repository-wide zero-reference claim is made.
Old pages/layouts/editors/import screens/document components are retained by the candidate register. Styles/tokens/hooks/utilities/dialogs/accessibility helpers have no proven unused candidate. Frontend routes and API endpoint compatibility have positive active examples; exhaustive external API-consumer absence is not established. Feature-flag inactivity is not obsolescence. Localisation keys, deprecated fixtures and dead assets need dynamic-key, bundle/export, test-discovery and historical-reference checks before any nomination. Dependency census must additionally cover conditional imports, build/test tooling, scripts, Docker and platform-specific paths; inspection of package metadata alone cannot prove non-use. Persisted-data inventories were not queried and no user data was opened. This is a bounded assessment, not a completed exhaustive dead-code proof.
## Historical data, SQLite and architecture
Retain canonical Career Profile separately from CV overrides, inherited settings, historical versions, frozen submitted HTML/binaries, letters and application associations. Retain historical extraction runs and review/accept DTOs. No migration, data rewrite, route alias removal or renderer replacement is proposed. Actual old-document load/export verification is NOT RUN in this turn.
Read `docs/database/mariadb-standardisation/README.md`, `ACCEPTANCE.md` and `SQLITE_RETIREMENT.md`. Retirement remains PLAN READY / REMOVAL NO-GO. The six gates require operator installation inventory, complete consistent export plus isolated restore, full-fidelity copied-data transfer, MariaDB coverage parity including direct SQLite harnesses, approved cutover with rollback after new writes, and retention-window sign-off. Existing partial export cannot establish lossless migration. No evidence reviewed closes those gates. Keep SQLite packages/helpers/provider branches and historical migrations. Track retirement independently; it does not block unrelated safe Phase 10 assessment or future qualified cleanup.
Architecture improvements delivered here: none to product code. The report clarifies ownership and deletion boundaries. Removed files/dependencies: none. Performance/build-size differences: NOT MEASURED; no claimed improvement. Rollback for this assessment is removal/reversion of this report only, with no data or product rollback needed. Any future implementation requires its own exact reversible patch and compatibility strategy.
## Preservation and validation handoff
Read Phase 9 preservation Markdown and parsed `p9-requal-01/preservation.json`. Carry all 57 IDs: E01–E09, J01–J10, W01–W12, C01–C12, M01–M06, S01–S05, A01–A03. Retain 56 PARTIAL / C11 DEFERRED, not PASS. Original 33-route register plus admin processing remains the 34-route preservation scope; wildcard/root routing must not be confused with independently accepted capabilities. App registration inspection is not end-to-end verification of every route.
Worker product tests, browser/visual checks, MariaDB, sidecar/Docling, PDF fidelity, types, lint, build, security, accessibility, EN/Bokmål and historical-document runtime checks: **NOT RUN**. No fresh test counts are claimed. Supplied prior full-suite evidence remains historical: backend 1448, frontend 1031, affected Windows browser 51, separate import 8/MariaDB 90+3/RD21 6/admission 1/Linux 8, Python 83 + Docling 14, and both-platform exports, each retaining original execution identity and limitations. Original S01 28/20 failures remain historical; approved metric requalification 36/36 per platform is not a new export or physical print test.
Controller must independently execute approved fixed suite IDs against the immutable handoff candidate: `backend-canary`, `frontend-canary`, `typecheck`, `lint`, `build`, `browser-canary`, `mariadb-canary`, `rd21-canary`, `python-canary`, `parser-security`, `docling-canary`, `pdf-linux-canary`. Require exact nonempty membership, process exits, source/freshness binding, no concealed failures/skips/retries, and cleanup evidence. No representative canary result can be reported as a fresh complete regression. Controller owns private receipt verification, publication and checkpoint acceptance. If identity/source correspondence fails, do not reuse historical evidence or advance.
## Decisions and next protected boundary
| Decision | Status |
| --- | --- |
| P10-00 report handoff | Complete for independent checks; acceptance pending controller verification. |
| Phase 10 overall | NO-GO for completion/implementation beyond assessment; no removal eligibility or P10-01 scope approved. |
| Redesign development completion | CONDITIONAL GO remains limited to inherited development/preparation acceptance; final cleanup completion not established. |
| Product review readiness | NO-GO for post-Phase-10 acceptance handoff; this is a preparatory debt/ownership report only. |
| Production release | NO-GO. |
Remaining debt: human physical-device/AT/contrast/EN-NB/printing checks NOT TESTED; real CV AI BLOCKED and disabled; deterministic recall/review burden and canonical-only generic-AI context limitations retained; Python vendor advisory incompleteness, hosted CI isolation, production TLS/advisories, native processing, filesystem/off-disk backup/restore and deployed identity remain separately unresolved. No risk acceptance, model activation, provider activation, schema change, main merge or deployment occurred.
PRODUCT-REVIEW-01 preparatory handoff: preserve all contracts and individual debt dispositions, review canonical-only generic-AI context separately, and do not infer production readiness from UI/PDF appearance approval. Final phase-10 deliverables under `docs/redesign/phase-10/`, full regression reconciliation and post-redesign acceptance remain future work outside the current writable/approved report scope.
TODO: controller verifies candidate/Git identity and independent checks; owner reviews this no-removal recommendation at the protected stop. A later request must name exact symbols, callers/routes/dynamic exports, old-data consumers, affected preservation IDs, compatibility transition, rollback and focused/full applicable tests. No P10-01 work should begin without that signed candidate-specific scope. If no candidate gains proof, retain it rather than invent cleanup work.