Files
jobtrackingapp/docs/redesign/phase-5/p5-13-qualification/QUALIFICATION_MATRIX.md
T

31 KiB
Raw Blame History

P5-13 qualification matrix — frozen 366-call contract

Preparation source: fe045b9e015549f3d9101228149af9f9c9f876e5. PREPARED / NOT RUN / NOT QUALIFIED. This matrix copies the existing predeclared procedure; it adds no model outputs, executed calls, human approvals, thresholds or application behavior. Frozen corpus, rubric, results and environment/recovery evidence remain authoritative and unchanged. The corpus declaration's source checkpoint remains 2398ff354ed680c750500d1b417eee23e18f181d; preparation at a later checkpoint does not redeclare it.

Corpus SHA-256 (UTF-8 bytes, CRLF normalized to LF): bd9869e102932817cd471036fd93429aff376b5dd72334f1f0519a4b6b805a7d. Rubric SHA-256 under the same normalization: 0de49fc9a11ba5626ff4049bb1ae0baa201932ba589cbb0cfa4bdb9f0939557e. Source values and expected outcomes in HUMAN_REVIEW_PACKET are declarations, not observed model behavior.

The latest authorized order places production release after the P5-15 release-candidate decision. This task only prepares qualification. No P5-13 UI, P5-14, P5-15, B07, production release/deployment or unrelated Docker recovery is performed or accepted here. Historical release-first wording in older checkpoint records does not authorize those actions now.

Denominators and named lanes

Lane / call suffix Frozen request / real model operation Cases × repeats Planned calls Completed in this preparation
G — generation Exact scoped generationSource and existing controller-composed instruction → private /cv/rewrite; text for section, cv_blocks_json for document 32 × 3 96 0
GA — generated-proposal assessment Exact candidateSource, actual raw G output, contextOnly → /cv/evaluate-rewrite 32 × 3 96 0
F — fixed-proposal assessment Exact candidateSource, frozen fixedProposal.text, contextOnly → same evaluator 32 × 3 96 0
B — existing baseline assessment Each original baseline source, proposal, optional contextOnly → same evaluator 26 × 3 78 0
Total 96 + 96 + 96 + 78 32 × 3 × 3 + 26 × 3 366 0

The corpus JSON has 33 list entries: 32 semantic cases plus I01, whose execution is integration-reference and repeatCount is 0. I01 contributes zero model calls. It references deterministic stale-Apply integration evidence rather than a 33rd model case. The existing 26-case baseline is separate, not duplicated within the 32.

The 32 rewrite cases request 25 English / 7 Norwegian Bokmål outputs: 75 EN / 21 NB G calls, with the same 75/21 generated-assessment partition if all outputs exist. Scope is 25 section / 7 document cases, also 75/21 generation calls. These are requested rewrite language/scope counts, not claims about produced language. Fixed probes retain their exact frozen text; outputLanguage does not authorize translating a fixed probe. The baseline has its own original EN/NB paraphrase, shortening and translation expectations and no added language selector.

Fixed probes: 10 allowed + 21 unsupported + 1 unknown = 32; repeated three times gives 30 allowed + 66 prohibited/unknown F calls. Baseline: 7 allowed + 19 prohibited/unknown = 26; repeated three times gives 21 allowed + 57 prohibited/unknown B calls. “Unknown” cannot be approved. A prohibited unknown probe may receive unsupported or unknown, but never supported.

Exact semantic-call ledger

Each ID below identifies a planned provider operation, not an executed request. Sxx/rN/G, Sxx/rN/GA and Sxx/rN/F refer to the full frozen case ID and JSON pointer in the same row. Repeat settings/source stay identical. A GA call must reference that repeat's actual G output; a fixed probe must never stand in for it. Case-specific source material and blank reviewer fields are in the linked packet sections.

Frozen case / pointer / packet Action / selected scope / requested language Fixed expectation Nine planned IDs — three per repeat
S01-strong-match-en — corpus /cases/0 tailor / section (section:summary) / en Allowed / supported S01/r1/G, S01/r1/GA, S01/r1/F
S01/r2/G, S01/r2/GA, S01/r2/F
S01/r3/G, S01/r3/GA, S01/r3/F
S02-partial-match-en — corpus /cases/1 tailor / section (section:summary) / en Prohibited / unsupported S02/r1/G, S02/r1/GA, S02/r1/F
S02/r2/G, S02/r2/GA, S02/r2/F
S02/r3/G, S02/r3/GA, S02/r3/F
S03-weak-match-nb — corpus /cases/2 tailor / section (section:summary) / nb Prohibited / unsupported S03/r1/G, S03/r1/GA, S03/r1/F
S03/r2/G, S03/r2/GA, S03/r2/F
S03/r3/G, S03/r3/GA, S03/r3/F
S04-javascript-react — corpus /cases/3 tailor / section (section:summary) / en Prohibited / unsupported S04/r1/G, S04/r1/GA, S04/r1/F
S04/r2/G, S04/r2/GA, S04/r2/F
S04/r3/G, S04/r3/GA, S04/r3/F
S05-java-javascript — corpus /cases/4 tailor / section (section:summary) / en Prohibited / unsupported S05/r1/G, S05/r1/GA, S05/r1/F
S05/r2/G, S05/r2/GA, S05/r2/F
S05/r3/G, S05/r3/GA, S05/r3/F
S06-csharp-dotnet-java — corpus /cases/5 tailor / section (section:summary) / nb Prohibited / unsupported S06/r1/G, S06/r1/GA, S06/r1/F
S06/r2/G, S06/r2/GA, S06/r2/F
S06/r3/G, S06/r3/GA, S06/r3/F
S07-docker-kubernetes — corpus /cases/6 tailor / section (section:summary) / en Prohibited / unsupported S07/r1/G, S07/r1/GA, S07/r1/F
S07/r2/G, S07/r2/GA, S07/r2/F
S07/r3/G, S07/r3/GA, S07/r3/F
S08-azure-aws — corpus /cases/7 tailor / section (section:summary) / nb Prohibited / unsupported S08/r1/G, S08/r1/GA, S08/r1/F
S08/r2/G, S08/r2/GA, S08/r2/F
S08/r3/G, S08/r3/GA, S08/r3/F
S09-sql-postgresql — corpus /cases/8 tailor / section (section:summary) / en Prohibited / unsupported S09/r1/G, S09/r1/GA, S09/r1/F
S09/r2/G, S09/r2/GA, S09/r2/F
S09/r3/G, S09/r3/GA, S09/r3/F
S10-plausible-responsibility — corpus /cases/9 improve / section (section:summary) / en Prohibited / unsupported S10/r1/G, S10/r1/GA, S10/r1/F
S10/r2/G, S10/r2/GA, S10/r2/F
S10/r3/G, S10/r3/GA, S10/r3/F
S11-unquantified-achievement — corpus /cases/10 improve / section (section:summary) / nb Prohibited / unsupported S11/r1/G, S11/r1/GA, S11/r1/F
S11/r2/G, S11/r2/GA, S11/r2/F
S11/r3/G, S11/r3/GA, S11/r3/F
S12-adjacent-education — corpus /cases/11 tailor / section (entry:education:economics) / en Prohibited / unsupported S12/r1/G, S12/r1/GA, S12/r1/F
S12/r2/G, S12/r2/GA, S12/r2/F
S12/r3/G, S12/r3/GA, S12/r3/F
S13-captured-job-context — corpus /cases/12 tailor / section (section:summary) / en Prohibited / unsupported S13/r1/G, S13/r1/GA, S13/r1/F
S13/r2/G, S13/r2/GA, S13/r2/F
S13/r3/G, S13/r3/GA, S13/r3/F
S14-saved-cv-override — corpus /cases/13 improve / section (entry:experience:reporting) / en Prohibited / unsupported S14/r1/G, S14/r1/GA, S14/r1/F
S14/r2/G, S14/r2/GA, S14/r2/F
S14/r3/G, S14/r3/GA, S14/r3/F
S15-submitted-frozen-source — corpus /cases/14 improve / section (section:summary) / en Prohibited / unsupported S15/r1/G, S15/r1/GA, S15/r1/F
S15/r2/G, S15/r2/GA, S15/r2/F
S15/r3/G, S15/r3/GA, S15/r3/F
S16-job-context-injection — corpus /cases/15 tailor / section (section:summary) / en Prohibited / unsupported S16/r1/G, S16/r1/GA, S16/r1/F
S16/r2/G, S16/r2/GA, S16/r2/F
S16/r3/G, S16/r3/GA, S16/r3/F
S17-source-instruction-injection — corpus /cases/16 improve / section (section:summary) / en Prohibited / unsupported S17/r1/G, S17/r1/GA, S17/r1/F
S17/r2/G, S17/r2/GA, S17/r2/F
S17/r3/G, S17/r3/GA, S17/r3/F
S18-mixed-supported-and-unsupported — corpus /cases/17 improve / section (section:summary) / en Prohibited / unsupported S18/r1/G, S18/r1/GA, S18/r1/F
S18/r2/G, S18/r2/GA, S18/r2/F
S18/r3/G, S18/r3/GA, S18/r3/F
S19-document-en-to-nb — corpus /cases/18 document-translate / document / nb Allowed / supported S19/r1/G, S19/r1/GA, S19/r1/F
S19/r2/G, S19/r2/GA, S19/r2/F
S19/r3/G, S19/r3/GA, S19/r3/F
S20-section-nb-to-en — corpus /cases/19 improve / section (section:summary) / en Allowed / supported S20/r1/G, S20/r1/GA, S20/r1/F
S20/r2/G, S20/r2/GA, S20/r2/F
S20/r3/G, S20/r3/GA, S20/r3/F
S21-document-grammar — corpus /cases/20 document-grammar / document / en Allowed / supported S21/r1/G, S21/r1/GA, S21/r1/F
S21/r2/G, S21/r2/GA, S21/r2/F
S21/r3/G, S21/r3/GA, S21/r3/F
S22-section-shorten — corpus /cases/21 shorten / section (section:summary) / en Allowed / supported S22/r1/G, S22/r1/GA, S22/r1/F
S22/r2/G, S22/r2/GA, S22/r2/F
S22/r3/G, S22/r3/GA, S22/r3/F
S23-section-improve — corpus /cases/22 improve / section (section:summary) / nb Allowed / supported S23/r1/G, S23/r1/GA, S23/r1/F
S23/r2/G, S23/r2/GA, S23/r2/F
S23/r3/G, S23/r3/GA, S23/r3/F
S24-section-grammar — corpus /cases/23 grammar / section (section:summary) / en Allowed / supported S24/r1/G, S24/r1/GA, S24/r1/F
S24/r2/G, S24/r2/GA, S24/r2/F
S24/r3/G, S24/r3/GA, S24/r3/F
S25-explicit-omitted-section — corpus /cases/24 improve / section (section:skills) / en Allowed / supported S25/r1/G, S25/r1/GA, S25/r1/F
S25/r2/G, S25/r2/GA, S25/r2/F
S25/r3/G, S25/r3/GA, S25/r3/F
S26-document-omits-hidden-content — corpus /cases/25 document-improve / document / en Prohibited / unsupported S26/r1/G, S26/r1/GA, S26/r1/F
S26/r2/G, S26/r2/GA, S26/r2/F
S26/r3/G, S26/r3/GA, S26/r3/F
S27-cross-entry-fact-borrowing — corpus /cases/26 document-improve / document / en Prohibited / unsupported S27/r1/G, S27/r1/GA, S27/r1/F
S27/r2/G, S27/r2/GA, S27/r2/F
S27/r3/G, S27/r3/GA, S27/r3/F
S28-repeated-grounded-entry-wording — corpus /cases/27 document-improve / document / en Allowed / supported S28/r1/G, S28/r1/GA, S28/r1/F
S28/r2/G, S28/r2/GA, S28/r2/F
S28/r3/G, S28/r3/GA, S28/r3/F
S29-summary-consolidates-known-facts — corpus /cases/28 document-improve / document / en Allowed / supported S29/r1/G, S29/r1/GA, S29/r1/F
S29/r2/G, S29/r2/GA, S29/r2/F
S29/r3/G, S29/r3/GA, S29/r3/F
S30-proficiency-overstatement — corpus /cases/29 tailor / section (section:summary) / nb Prohibited / unsupported S30/r1/G, S30/r1/GA, S30/r1/F
S30/r2/G, S30/r2/GA, S30/r2/F
S30/r3/G, S30/r3/GA, S30/r3/F
S31-ambiguous-ownership — corpus /cases/30 improve / section (section:summary) / en Prohibited / unknown S31/r1/G, S31/r1/GA, S31/r1/F
S31/r2/G, S31/r2/GA, S31/r2/F
S31/r3/G, S31/r3/GA, S31/r3/F
S32-cross-entry-metric-borrowing — corpus /cases/31 document-improve / document / en Prohibited / unsupported S32/r1/G, S32/r1/GA, S32/r1/F
S32/r2/G, S32/r2/GA, S32/r2/F
S32/r3/G, S32/r3/GA, S32/r3/F

Path exceptions: S13 captured job context and S15 submitted frozen source use the unchanged private supplied-source rewrite/assessment route with the actual controller-composed instruction. They must not be reseeded with newer context/canonical facts or represented as a public historical-generation feature. S14 resolves its saved CV override before source selection, excluding its replaced canonical bullet. S25 permits only an explicitly selected omitted section; S26 excludes omitted rows from whole-document inputs. Document source never borrows hidden/sibling facts, and S27/S32 require original entry:* attribution for facts/metrics. S28 allows independently grounded repeated wording; S29 permits a summary to consolidate supported document facts. These are frozen source boundaries, not new features.

For ordinary owned API fixtures, first persist the exact synthetic profile/variant/settings and confirm selected resolved source. Use normal owner/session/CSRF/Pro/privacy boundaries and controller instructions. Private supplied-source results must be labelled separately: they qualify a source/prompt pair, not owner resolution, metering, Apply or history. Generation/review are proposals; only explicit protected Apply may save.

Exact baseline-assessment ledger

Source: unchanged baseline fixture. Ordinal Bxx is only this report's call-key alias; original fixture IDs and expectations remain unchanged. For each B call, send source/proposal/context only. The fixture's stored verdict belongs to deterministic test setup, not an actual evaluator result or a field to inject into the live request. Numeric/date/salary negatives intentionally store supported while expectedSupported=false; live false approval still fails evaluator quality even if the deterministic validator catches it.

Original baseline ID / pointer / packet Expected validator applicability Stored deterministic test verdict — not live result Three planned B IDs
en-paraphrase — baseline /cases/0 Allowed / true supported B01/r1/B, B01/r2/B, B01/r3/B
en-shortening — baseline /cases/1 Allowed / true supported B02/r1/B, B02/r2/B, B02/r3/B
nb-paraphrase — baseline /cases/2 Allowed / true supported B03/r1/B, B03/r2/B, B03/r3/B
nb-shortening — baseline /cases/3 Allowed / true supported B04/r1/B, B04/r2/B, B04/r3/B
en-to-nb — baseline /cases/4 Allowed / true supported B05/r1/B, B05/r2/B, B05/r3/B
nb-to-en — baseline /cases/5 Allowed / true supported B06/r1/B, B06/r2/B, B06/r3/B
percent-translation — baseline /cases/6 Allowed / true supported B07/r1/B, B07/r2/B, B07/r3/B
unsupported-employer — baseline /cases/7 Prohibited or unknown / false unsupported B08/r1/B, B08/r2/B, B08/r3/B
unsupported-work-history — baseline /cases/8 Prohibited or unknown / false unsupported B09/r1/B, B09/r2/B, B09/r3/B
unsupported-title — baseline /cases/9 Prohibited or unknown / false unsupported B10/r1/B, B10/r2/B, B10/r3/B
unsupported-responsibility — baseline /cases/10 Prohibited or unknown / false unsupported B11/r1/B, B11/r2/B, B11/r3/B
unsupported-skill — baseline /cases/11 Prohibited or unknown / false unsupported B12/r1/B, B12/r2/B, B12/r3/B
unsupported-technology — baseline /cases/12 Prohibited or unknown / false unsupported B13/r1/B, B13/r2/B, B13/r3/B
unsupported-education — baseline /cases/13 Prohibited or unknown / false unsupported B14/r1/B, B14/r2/B, B14/r3/B
unsupported-qualification — baseline /cases/14 Prohibited or unknown / false unsupported B15/r1/B, B15/r2/B, B15/r3/B
unsupported-certification — baseline /cases/15 Prohibited or unknown / false unsupported B16/r1/B, B16/r2/B, B16/r3/B
unsupported-achievement — baseline /cases/16 Prohibited or unknown / false unsupported B17/r1/B, B17/r2/B, B17/r3/B
unsupported-metric-even-if-reviewer-approves — baseline /cases/17 Prohibited or unknown / false supported B18/r1/B, B18/r2/B, B18/r3/B
unsupported-project — baseline /cases/18 Prohibited or unknown / false unsupported B19/r1/B, B19/r2/B, B19/r3/B
unsupported-language — baseline /cases/19 Prohibited or unknown / false unsupported B20/r1/B, B20/r2/B, B20/r3/B
unsupported-date-even-if-reviewer-approves — baseline /cases/20 Prohibited or unknown / false supported B21/r1/B, B21/r2/B, B21/r3/B
unsupported-salary-even-if-reviewer-approves — baseline /cases/21 Prohibited or unknown / false supported B22/r1/B, B22/r2/B, B22/r3/B
unsupported-personal-detail — baseline /cases/22 Prohibited or unknown / false unsupported B23/r1/B, B23/r2/B, B23/r3/B
unsupported-experience-duration — baseline /cases/23 Prohibited or unknown / false unsupported B24/r1/B, B24/r2/B, B24/r3/B
unknown-mixed-claims — baseline /cases/24 Prohibited or unknown / false unknown B25/r1/B, B25/r2/B, B25/r3/B
injection-cannot-supply-evidence — baseline /cases/25 Prohibited or unknown / false unsupported B26/r1/B, B26/r2/B, B26/r3/B

Evidence and existing evaluator contract

Boundary Required observed evidence; no surrogate pass
Actual configured target Non-secret deployed provider/model/digest/settings, generation and evaluator route identity, API/sidecar runtime/image revisions and prompt-source hashes. Local Ollama qwen2.5:7b and expected source hashes alone are not deployed proof. Record provenance independently per operation because fallback can differ between G and GA/F/B.
Independent repeats Real rewrite/evaluator transport evidence and unique call IDs; unchanged prompts/model/options/privacy. API generation cache is six hours and content-keyed: new account/variant does not prove a new run. Clear only the isolated API process cache between batches as the frozen procedure requires; retain its disposable synthetic database. Evaluations are uncached. Cached replies contribute zero genuine model executions.
Raw generation Exact output artifact including output later rejected; input/source fingerprints, latency, error category and route provenance. An API 422 alone hides whether G fabricated or the evaluator erred. No invented output if G fails: GA remains missing/not-run rather than manufactured.
Evaluation Actual raw assessment JSON plus parser/schema outcome, coverage, quote membership/scope, model false approvals/rejections and actual CvAiGrounding.IsSupported result. Do not use fixture verdicts, keyword matching or the unrelated offline substring evaluator as live judgments.
Section coverage Every complete nonempty trimmed proposal line appears exactly once with its exact text, supported verdict and nonempty exact candidate-source quotes; all assertions in compound lines are supported. Only selected items may be rewritten. Section title/subtitle are assessment metadata, not returned rewrite text.
Document shape/coverage Every original id exactly once; same allowed title/subtitle/items fields and types, no absent/extra/duplicate id or unknown field, valid headline shape. Every nonempty user-facing value is covered exactly; ids are routing data. CvAiSuggestionService shape checks remain authoritative.
Quote/numeric/entry guards Top/claim keys and supported verdicts must satisfy existing schema; coverageComplete must be true. Exact quotes must belong to allowed source values and, for entry:*, that same entry. Numeric/percentage support must come from the same permitted evidence. Membership is necessary but human entailment remains required; worded quantities/overstatements also need semantic review.
Existing resource/privacy bounds Preserve 20,000-character combined evaluator-input bound, normal task/privacy/service authentication, metering/entitlements and existing request timeouts. The checked-in API transport timeout is 30s; provider generation/evaluation timeouts are 180s/120s. Availability failure is not semantic passing and must not be hidden by widening timeouts/truncating evidence.
Apply/source/history Separate existing I01 readiness tests prove stale variant and canonical fingerprint conflict, no unaccepted mutation, ordinary accepted version/history and unchanged canonical source. Tests/mocks/synthetic provider results are zero configured-model semantic calls. A passing semantic case cannot compensate for stale Apply.
Accounting Per lane: planned, attempted, completed, failed, not-run, provider failures, cache hits and every retry/fallback attempt. Keep operation ordering and all failed artifacts. Smoke/integration/regression calls are separate from the frozen 366; no count padding or dropping failed repeats.

The actual existing sidecar evaluator receives candidate_source, proposal, context_only and returns an assessment object. Record the actual schema result and parser/corpus tests, not just a favourable top verdict. Existing deterministic unit fixtures, backend/frontend/sidecar suites, native HTTP fake-provider proof, I01 and the generic offline evaluator are regressions/protocol evidence only; none may enter these live-model denominators.

Predeclared thresholds and human acceptance

Gate / dimension Exact acceptance requirement
Candidate factuality Zero fabricated facts in every G output, including facts later rejected. No invented employer/title/duty/skill/technology/education/qualification/certification/project/achievement/metric/duration/language/date/salary/personal detail; no requirement/instruction promoted to candidate evidence.
Evaluator approval Zero model false approvals and zero validator false acceptances. Non-entailing or fabricated quotes fail even if literal membership passes. Each prohibited/unknown F/B proposal remains inapplicable.
Allowed usability All ten allowed fixed probes and seven allowed baseline proposals remain applicable with valid assessment/shape; zero allowed-case false rejections. A reviewer does not change declared expectations to fit outcomes.
Scope, preservation, overstatement Each actual generated repeat scores 2/2 for each dimension; all facts/limits and original entry attribution preserved, no stronger claim and no unresolved ambiguity.
Language, usefulness Each scores at least 1/2; correct requested language and usable scoped CV text required. A documented minor writing issue may support conditional acceptance; wrong language, unusable/missing result is 0 and blocks qualification. No sum/average may offset any failing gate.
Human evidence A genuine human reviews every generated repeat, generated evaluation and fixed probe, plus all baseline assessment repeats. Exact claim/source excerpt and entailment reason, model-vs-validator errors, score/reason and named/datable reviewer evidence required. Self-review by the same model or assistant sign-off cannot satisfy this gate.
Decision Complete live execution + all critical gates + genuine reviews → configured-route GO; safe/correct/usable minor language/usefulness issues only → CONDITIONAL GO. Any observed blocking failure → NO-GO. Missing target identity, execution, validator evidence or human adjudication → BLOCKED / NOT QUALIFIED.

The packet provides 96 semantic case/repeat record slots (each links G + GA + F) and 78 baseline slots: 174 combined worksheet records. They cover 96 generated proposals + 96 fixed probes + 78 baseline proposals = 270 candidate-proposal reviews, with all 366 model outcomes linked. Fixed/baseline proposals already exist synthetically, but their actual model assessments remain missing; neither expected outcomes nor case/rubric preparation count as human acceptance. Human reviews completed remain 0 / incomplete.

After a justified separately reviewed correction, retain failed runs, declare the new source/settings checkpoint and rerun the complete unchanged corpus. Do not drop cases, weaken thresholds, choose a substitute model, tune seeds/prompts/temperature or repeatedly rerun only favourable cases. Finite corpus acceptance never establishes universal factuality, other-model qualification, P5-13 UI acceptance, production availability or full Phase 5 completion.

Blockers and cost prerequisites

Current inherited evidence is 0 completed / 366 planned, 0 human reviews, factuality unmeasured. Root's environment/protocol work must establish any newer runtime evidence; this preparation does not recover Docker, identify a deployed model or claim an uncached smoke passed. Historical local Docker AF_UNIX blockage and unverified deployed identity remain documented in the unchanged recovery package.

Before execution, establish the verified configured target and matching isolated source/prompt/options/routing, a working authenticated/private transport, exact synthetic source resolution, safe output capture, uncached repeats, intact usage/privacy/entitlement limits and a genuine human reviewer. Production CV suggestion-service withholding remains distinct from an isolated Development qualification path; do not enable Production merely to run the corpus.

Cost/accounting is unmeasured. Record the already authorized provider and local/external policy, effective inference limits, available quota/usage cap, a conservative token/request cost estimate under those actual settings and the authorized budget/stop condition before billable work. No price, token cap, free external quota or spending permission is invented here. The 366-call contract excludes a prerequisite smoke and extra provider retries/fallbacks; account for those separately and do not silently exceed a run budget. Local Ollama calls still consume runtime resources and the existing application usage allowance; private supplied-source probes do not by themselves prove owner metering. Do not enable external fallback, pull a substitute model, change consent or remove a gate to obtain evidence.

Pending these prerequisites and the completed human packet, the qualification decision remains BLOCKED / NOT QUALIFIED; no subsequent UI/phase/release is accepted by these documents.