51 lines
7.1 KiB
Markdown
51 lines
7.1 KiB
Markdown
---
|
||
verdict: needs-remediation
|
||
remediation_round: 0
|
||
---
|
||
|
||
# Milestone Validation: M001
|
||
|
||
## Success Criteria Checklist
|
||
- [x] Criterion 1 — evidence: S02 wired `POST /api/jobapplications/{id}/generate-application-package` to imported correspondence, recruiter/job/profile context, and persisted package workspace state in `JobDetailsDialog.tsx`; focused backend/frontend tests prove generate/edit/save/reload behavior for tailored CV, cover letter, recruiter message, and application-answer drafts.
|
||
- [x] Criterion 2 — evidence: S01 delivered job-scoped Gmail candidate ranking, single-message and full-thread import, persisted Gmail metadata, and correspondence workspace rendering; focused backend/frontend tests substantiate lower-cleanup import behavior and timeline/workspace reflection.
|
||
- [x] Criterion 3 — evidence: S01 added `POST /api/gmail/refresh-linked-threads` plus persisted `ExternalThreadId`/`ExternalMessageId`, and both S01 and S05 report duplicate-safe linked-thread refresh that imports later replies into the same job without manual re-import.
|
||
- [x] Criterion 4 — evidence: S03 added context-grounded follow-up drafting from imported correspondence plus saved package material and kept the explicit manual-send boundary; focused backend/frontend tests and follow-up workspace behavior substantiate the drafting loop.
|
||
- [x] Criterion 5 — evidence: S04 and S05 align `/jobs`, `/dashboard`, `/reminders`, and the per-job workspace around one routed control loop, with daily-loop and integrated trust-loop tests covering the shared workflow path.
|
||
- [x] Criterion 6 — evidence: S03 and S05 preserve the manual-send boundary; drafting/regeneration stays separate from `send-followup`, and requirement R008 remains constrained/active.
|
||
- [ ] Integrated live re-check against real behavior — gap: milestone definition of done requires success criteria to be re-checked against live behavior and final integrated acceptance scenarios to pass, but the available evidence remains mostly contract/test-based. S01 explicitly says live Gmail UAT was not executed, S05 says full live UAT still depends on resolving the backend CORS/runtime mismatch on `http://localhost:5202`, and the milestone does not yet contain executed end-to-end acceptance results for the full real loop.
|
||
|
||
## Slice Delivery Audit
|
||
| Slice | Claimed | Delivered | Status |
|
||
|-------|---------|-----------|--------|
|
||
| S01 | User can connect Gmail, review likely messages/threads for a job, import a message or full thread, and trust linked Gmail threads to stay current without manual re-import. | Summary substantiates ranked job-aware Gmail candidates, duplicate-safe single-message/thread import, persisted Gmail metadata, and linked-thread refresh on known job-linked threads. | pass |
|
||
| S02 | Imported job plus profile/CV context generates materially better tailored CV and cover-letter drafts that feel specific and usable. | Summary substantiates stronger package-context assembly plus persisted generate/edit/save/reset workspace for package artifacts. | pass |
|
||
| S03 | Inside a job, the user can generate follow-up and reply drafts grounded in imported/auto-refreshed correspondence plus saved application context, then edit before sending manually. | Summary substantiates grounded follow-up drafting, exposed context metadata, editable draft flow, and explicit manual-send/log boundary. | pass |
|
||
| S04 | Job table becomes primary overview and dashboard/follow-up surfaces clearly show what needs attention next. | Summary substantiates routed dashboard/reminders/job-table actions and focused UI/browser proof, but the checked-in `S04-UAT.md` is still a doctor-created placeholder rather than a real executed UAT artifact. | needs-attention |
|
||
| S05 | Full loop works cleanly in a real environment: import job → generate package → apply externally → import/update correspondence automatically → draft follow-up/reply → track progress confidently. | Summary substantiates shared workflow-signal contract, visible package/continuity trust state, and integrated regression coverage, but also states full live UAT is still blocked by backend CORS/runtime mismatch, so the “real environment” claim is not yet fully closed. | fail |
|
||
|
||
## Cross-Slice Integration
|
||
- S01 → S02: aligned. S02 explicitly consumes imported correspondence and recruiter/thread context from S01 in package generation.
|
||
- S01 → S03: aligned. S03 builds follow-up context from persisted correspondence and linked-thread metadata instead of transient Gmail candidates.
|
||
- S02 → S03: aligned. S03 reuses saved package fields and the marker-delimited application-answer block established in S02.
|
||
- S03 → S04: aligned. S04 routes users into the Follow-up and Tailored CV workspace tabs rather than inventing a second compose loop.
|
||
- S04 → S05: partially aligned. S05 centralizes workflow signals and integrated routing as planned, but the boundary-map expectation of final live integration proof is not yet satisfied because the available evidence stops at tests plus limited browser shell verification.
|
||
|
||
## Requirement Coverage
|
||
- Coverage is mapped for all active requirements: R008 is addressed by S03/S05 and R009 is addressed by S04 (with later supporting slices planned outside M001).
|
||
- Validated requirements R001, R002, R003, R004, R005, R006, R007, and R010 all have at least one substantiating slice.
|
||
- No active requirement is completely unaddressed.
|
||
- Remaining concern is validation depth, not mapping breadth: milestone-level live proof is still missing for the integrated loop, and S04’s UAT artifact is incomplete.
|
||
|
||
## Verdict Rationale
|
||
`needs-remediation` because the milestone has strong implementation and regression-test evidence, but it does not yet meet its own definition of done for live integrated acceptance. The most material gaps are:
|
||
|
||
1. **No executed full-loop live acceptance evidence.** S01 deferred live Gmail UAT, and S05 explicitly reports that full browser UAT is still blocked by backend CORS/runtime mismatch.
|
||
2. **S05’s claimed “real environment” outcome is not fully substantiated.** The summary itself narrows proof to integrated tests plus limited browser shell verification.
|
||
3. **S04’s UAT artifact is still a placeholder.** Even though S04 summary references browser verification, the required human-verification artifact was not properly closed.
|
||
|
||
These are milestone-sealing gaps rather than cosmetic documentation issues, because M001 explicitly requires live behavior re-checks and final integrated acceptance scenarios before completion.
|
||
|
||
## Remediation Plan
|
||
- **S06: Live environment stabilization and end-to-end acceptance rerun** — fix the backend/frontend runtime/CORS mismatch for the M001 environment, then execute and record a real browser-based acceptance pass covering `/jobs` → workspace package state → Gmail linked-thread refresh/continuity → grounded follow-up draft → `/dashboard` and `/reminders` entry consistency, without violating the manual-send boundary.
|
||
- **S07: Daily-loop UAT artifact closure** — replace the placeholder `S04-UAT.md` with a real executed UAT record that confirms the overview surfaces and job workspace behave coherently for the same job, using the stabilized environment from S06.
|