docs: record full design reassessment and preserved gates

This commit is contained in:
cesnimda
2026-11-18 19:36:14 +01:00
parent 8d17e01c1c
commit b4e5fea2e5
4 changed files with 540 additions and 0 deletions
@@ -0,0 +1,518 @@
# Jobjakt — FULL DESIGN REASSESSMENT + CONTINUOUS ROADMAP DEVELOPMENT
## Owner direction
I want to reassess the entire Jobjakt design.
Although significant A3 implementation work has been completed, I am not entirely happy with the result.
**I am now open to completely redesigning Jobjakt from the ground up.**
I mean a genuinely new UI/UX direction, not another incremental restyling of the current application.
However, I also want you to continue working on EVERYTHING ELSE in my existing roadmap concurrently wherever safe.
Do not freeze the wider development backlog while we explore the design.
There are three parallel objectives:
A. Independently establish whether the existing A3 redesign is actually complete.
B. Explore a completely fresh Jobjakt experience, with no commitment to retaining A3's visual design or information architecture.
C. Continue implementing every other independently authorised roadmap task.
---
# PART A — Verify A3 completion
First, inspect the actual repository, worktrees, commits, application and authoritative records.
Latest reported checkpoints:
- Application: `2c5d0451`
- Roadmap: `8d17e01c`
Verify the true current state.
Read:
- `docs/direct-roadmap/ROADMAP_TODO.md`
- `docs/direct-roadmap/ROADMAP_STATUS.md`
- `docs/direct-roadmap/LATEST_CHECKPOINT.md`
- A3 design handoff and implementation records.
- IM01–IM10 acceptance evidence.
- Applicable Phase 10 and preservation requirements.
Audit all 34 routes and 57 preservation groups.
Determine:
- Which redesign milestones are implemented.
- Which are properly tested.
- Which have owner approval.
- Which are incomplete.
- Which have outstanding visual discrepancies.
- Which are awaiting real backend, mobile, accessibility or security qualification.
- Whether any old design patterns remain.
Capture current real application screenshots at desktop, tablet and mobile widths.
Check English, Norwegian, light and dark modes.
Do not declare the redesign complete merely because components were migrated or tests passed.
Produce a clear conclusion:
- COMPLETE AND ACCEPTED.
- IMPLEMENTED BUT AWAITING ACCEPTANCE.
- PARTIALLY IMPLEMENTED.
- INCOMPLETE.
Explain the result with evidence.
The owner has not granted final A3 visual acceptance.
Do not silently close that gate.
Also reconcile the recovered CV journey proposal whose baseline still requires verification.
---
# PART B — Complete UX rethink from scratch
## 1. Start with a blank design canvas
I am explicitly releasing the design exploration from previous A3 visual constraints.
You may fundamentally rethink:
- Visual identity.
- Colour system.
- Typography.
- Navigation.
- Page structure.
- Information architecture.
- Dashboard.
- Application tracking.
- Job discovery.
- CV Builder.
- Career Profile.
- Cover letters.
- Calendar.
- Correspondence.
- Onboarding.
- Settings.
- Mobile navigation.
- Desktop workflows.
- Admin interface.
- Shared design system.
Do not simply rearrange the existing cards.
Do not assume A3's sidebar, dashboard layout, editor position or existing interaction patterns must survive.
Evaluate them on their merits.
**The new interface should feel like an entirely new product.**
However, preserve the underlying application functionality and data integrity.
A new UI does not automatically require rewriting the backend, authentication system, database or other stable infrastructure.
Assess whether frontend architectural replacement is justified rather than assuming it is.
## 2. Research modern UX
Research successful contemporary SaaS products, job-search platforms, productivity applications, career tools and CV builders.
Examples worth examining include FlowCV, Linear, Notion, Teal and Huntr, alongside other relevant products.
Assess actual current interfaces rather than assuming past designs remain unchanged.
Study:
- Navigation simplicity.
- Information density.
- Visual hierarchy.
- Form usability.
- Responsive behaviour.
- Search and filtering.
- Progressive disclosure.
- Onboarding.
- Document editing.
- Status and workflow management.
- Accessibility.
- Perceived performance.
Identify patterns worth adopting.
Avoid copying another product's branding, assets or complete design.
## 3. Design for every jobseeker
Jobjakt is not a software-developer-only application.
It must work intuitively for people seeking work in:
- Technology.
- Healthcare.
- Education.
- Retail.
- Hospitality.
- Construction.
- Engineering.
- Administration.
- Public services.
- Skilled trades.
- And other occupations.
It must support beginners and experienced users.
Avoid interfaces that look like internal enterprise administration software.
Everyday users should understand important actions without technical knowledge.
Keep advanced features accessible without displaying every control at once.
## 4. European-first architecture
This remains non-negotiable.
Support the existing European expansion requirements:
- All 24 official EU languages.
- The approved additional European languages.
- Country-aware job searching.
- Accurate country-specific maps.
- Canonical geographic filtering.
- International occupations.
- Correct regional conventions.
- Multilingual documents.
- Independent UI, search and document language settings.
Design for longer translations and different writing systems from the beginning.
Do not design English-only screens and treat localisation as an afterthought.
## 5. Explore five genuinely distinct directions
Produce FIVE different high-fidelity design concepts.
They must differ meaningfully in:
- Information architecture.
- Navigation.
- Workspace organisation.
- Visual design.
- Density.
- Interaction patterns.
- Desktop and mobile behaviour.
Suggested starting points:
**Concept A — Minimal Productivity Workspace**
Fast, clean, understated, excellent information density.
**Concept B — Friendly Career Workspace**
Approachable, guided, welcoming and easy for beginners.
**Concept C — Career and Document Studio**
Strong focus on creating CVs, building profiles and preparing applications.
**Concept D — Premium Career Platform**
Distinctive branding, sophisticated interaction and polished consumer-product quality.
**Concept E — Your Own Recommendation**
An original direction based on the strongest research and an independent assessment of Jobjakt.
Do not produce five versions of the same layout with different colours.
Do not constrain the concepts to A3.
## 6. Show complete user experiences
For every concept, include representative desktop and mobile screens:
- Dashboard.
- Job discovery.
- Application list.
- Application details.
- Career Profile.
- CV Builder.
- Cover letters.
- Calendar.
- Correspondence.
- Settings.
- Administration.
- First-time onboarding.
Use realistic synthetic content.
Show actual density, states, controls and workflows.
Include light and dark themes.
Demonstrate how layouts adapt to mobile rather than simply shrinking desktop.
Explore how users move through complete journeys, including:
Discover job → inspect → save → apply → track → follow up.
Career Profile → prepare CV → review → export.
Interview invitation → calendar → preparation → follow-up.
## 7. Create working prototypes
Produce real, clickable browser prototypes where feasible.
I want to experience the different approaches, not merely read design descriptions.
Provide:
- A concept gallery.
- Desktop previews.
- Mobile previews.
- Interactive navigation.
- Representative editing interactions.
- Light/dark switching.
- English/Norwegian previews.
- Screenshots.
- A comparison of strengths, weaknesses and tradeoffs.
Use the approved development environment and synthetic data.
Do not deploy these prototypes to production.
If external inspiration or imagery is used, respect usage rights and attribution.
## 8. Challenge existing design decisions
Do not assume the current navigation is best.
Consider whether Jobjakt really needs its existing number of navigation destinations.
Explore grouping functionality into intuitive areas such as:
- Home.
- Explore.
- Applications.
- Career.
- Calendar.
- Account.
These are illustrative, not mandatory.
Think about whether jobs, correspondence, documents, interviews and follow-ups should be connected within one application workspace instead of spread across unrelated pages.
Look for opportunities to reduce the number of clicks needed to complete everyday tasks.
Keep advanced features discoverable.
Avoid excessive boxes inside boxes.
Use typography, spacing and purposeful layout divisions rather than decorative cards everywhere.
Do not mistake minimalism for hiding functionality.
## 9. Evaluate implementation strategies
Compare at least:
A. Thorough redesign using the existing React/component architecture.
B. Major frontend restructuring with new shared architecture and components.
C. A fresh frontend implementation built around the existing backend APIs.
Assess:
- Expected design freedom.
- Risk to preserved functionality.
- Development effort.
- Testing and migration cost.
- Accessibility.
- Performance.
- Maintainability.
- European localisation.
- Compatibility with current workstreams.
Recommend the best approach with evidence.
Do not automatically choose the most expensive rewrite.
Do not begin replacing the production frontend without owner approval.
## 10. Owner design review
Once the five concepts and comparison are ready, present them for review.
I want to be able to:
- Choose a preferred concept.
- Combine features from different concepts.
- Reject individual visual patterns.
- Request changes.
- Continue iterating until I am satisfied.
Do not assume I will choose the first recommended design.
Do not begin full replacement implementation until I explicitly approve the selected direction and implementation strategy.
While waiting for design feedback, continue independently authorised work elsewhere in the roadmap.
---
# PART C — Continue everything else
This is equally important.
**The new design exploration must NOT stop the rest of Jobjakt development.**
Continue the previously approved maximum-backlog execution directive.
Work through the entire existing TODO, including:
- Phase 10 eligible acceptance and integrity work.
- Product Review preparation.
- International Global Job Search.
- European localisation.
- EUROPE-READY geographic support.
- All applicable performance optimisations.
- Public homepage work within approved scope.
- Security and dependency remediation.
- Release readiness.
- Database and operational improvements.
- Existing technical debt.
- Outstanding functional and integration defects.
Respect existing gates.
Do not use the potential redesign as an excuse to abandon substantial previously completed work.
## Parallel execution
Where Codex supports safe parallel workers, establish independent ownership.
Suggested workstreams:
**Worker A — Existing A3 audit**
Establish actual completion and preservation status.
**Worker B — From-scratch UX research and concepts**
Produce new design options and prototypes without modifying live application behaviour.
**Worker C — European expansion**
Continue localisation, geographical architecture and independently authorised Global Jobs work.
**Worker D — Backend, security and performance**
Continue validated backend optimisations, dependency remediation, data integrity and operational improvements.
Use actual worker availability and reasonable hardware limits.
Run fewer workers if necessary.
Workers must not collide on shared files or mutable databases.
Assign separate branches/worktrees where appropriate.
## Avoid wasted implementation
Since we may replace the visual design completely, deprioritise discretionary cosmetic polishing of existing A3 components.
Still fix:
- Security vulnerabilities.
- Data loss.
- Incorrect functionality.
- Accessibility failures.
- User-isolation problems.
- High-impact defects.
Continue implementation of reusable business logic, APIs, localisation infrastructure, data models, tests and other design-independent work.
Do not remove accepted functionality because its existing presentation might be replaced.
## Continuous progress
After every validated implementation package:
1. Update the authoritative TODO.
2. Record tests and evidence.
3. Commit and publish when authorised.
4. Select the next independently eligible backlog task.
5. Continue immediately.
Do not stop merely to deliver small milestone summaries.
Maintain separate statuses for:
- Existing A3 completion.
- New redesign research.
- New redesign owner approval.
- New redesign implementation.
- Wider roadmap implementation.
- Final product acceptance.
Do not falsely mark the proposed redesign as implemented.
## Approval and safety boundaries
Maintain all existing restrictions:
- No autonomous orchestrator.
- No merge into main.
- No production deployment.
- No destructive migrations.
- No unapproved third-party costs.
- No bypassing mandatory owner decisions.
- No unqualified production AI/provider activation.
- No removal of protected historical data or functionality.
- No claims of acceptance without evidence.
Use prior verified test evidence where still applicable.
Batch owner decisions where possible.
However, the new design selection is an explicit mandatory owner gate.
Do not self-approve it.
## Required deliverables
### A3 assessment
A factual report explaining whether the existing redesign is complete, partial or awaiting acceptance.
### New design exploration
Five distinct interactive visual concepts with desktop/mobile coverage, screenshots and a comparative recommendation.
### Implementation recommendation
A reasoned comparison of updating, restructuring or replacing the frontend.
### Preservation analysis
Evidence showing how all current functionality and routes can survive a new design.
### Roadmap progress
Completed implementation, test results, commits, published changes, blockers and remaining authorised tasks.
### Owner decisions
A consolidated design-review package plus any other genuinely blocked decisions.
## Final directive
Begin immediately.
**Assess A3, explore a completely new Jobjakt design, and keep developing the remaining roadmap concurrently wherever safely possible.**
I am open to starting the user experience over from the ground up.
Do not restrict the exploration to the old A3 design.
Do not discard existing application functionality.
Do not pause other independent development work while design choices await my review.
Make substantial progress for as long as the execution environment permits.
The objective is to build the best possible Jobjakt experience for European jobseekers, not simply finish the existing design checklist.
+7
View File
@@ -1,5 +1,12 @@
# Direct execution continuation
## Full design reassessment authorised
Owner directive archived in DESIGN_REASSESSMENT_DIRECTIVE.md; SHA256 5b7fc4f837569f01286ba57fa07954d6fafae716611a3898387c595314a72de5. Exploration is released from A3 visual/navigation constraints. Five NEW distinct clickable concepts are requested; preserve original A3 prototypes and all functionality. No replacement implementation until explicit selected-direction AND strategy approval. A3 final visual acceptance remains absent. Separate statuses: existing A3 audit ACTIVE; new research/prototypes PENDING; new owner approval PENDING; replacement implementation NOT AUTHORISED; wider roadmap CONTINUES. All24 EU/all60 planned locale scope retained. Deprioritise discretionary A3 cosmetics; continue integrity/accessibility/business logic/performance and other eligible work.
Read-only/report worker design_reassessment_audit dispatched for34routes/57groups and IM01–10; owns only docs/ui-modernisation/reassessment/A3_ASSESSMENT.md. Second research worker creation failed at agent thread limit; no research/prototype work claimed. Root must perform research/prototypes sequentially or reuse an available worker without idle retries. Next: reconcile CV proposal baseline, inspect current official product interfaces, build five new concepts in an isolated design lab, capture real application desktop/tablet/mobile EN/NB light/dark separately. Existing checkpoint8d17e01c and A3 reported2c5d0451 remain baseline pending fresh audit.
## Recovery audit continuation
Roadmap encoding repair798c410e published/refverified; verified c18c69f8 historical checkpoint/status preserved verbatim with legitimate new entries.36 non-orchestrator worktrees inspected; snapshot retained at E:/Storage/Projects/Active/temp docs/jobjakt-local-build/browser-restoration-20261117/recovery-worktrees.json. Main checkout unrelated dirty files untouched. A3 remote2c5d0451 and performance remote2a212c78 verified.
+7
View File
@@ -1,5 +1,12 @@
# Direct roadmap status
## Full design reassessment authorised
Owner directive archived in DESIGN_REASSESSMENT_DIRECTIVE.md; SHA256 5b7fc4f837569f01286ba57fa07954d6fafae716611a3898387c595314a72de5. Exploration is released from A3 visual/navigation constraints. Five NEW distinct clickable concepts are requested; preserve original A3 prototypes and all functionality. No replacement implementation until explicit selected-direction AND strategy approval. A3 final visual acceptance remains absent. Separate statuses: existing A3 audit ACTIVE; new research/prototypes PENDING; new owner approval PENDING; replacement implementation NOT AUTHORISED; wider roadmap CONTINUES. All24 EU/all60 planned locale scope retained. Deprioritise discretionary A3 cosmetics; continue integrity/accessibility/business logic/performance and other eligible work.
Read-only/report worker design_reassessment_audit dispatched for34routes/57groups and IM01–10; owns only docs/ui-modernisation/reassessment/A3_ASSESSMENT.md. Second research worker creation failed at agent thread limit; no research/prototype work claimed. Root must perform research/prototypes sequentially or reuse an available worker without idle retries. Next: reconcile CV proposal baseline, inspect current official product interfaces, build five new concepts in an isolated design lab, capture real application desktop/tablet/mobile EN/NB light/dark separately. Existing checkpoint8d17e01c and A3 reported2c5d0451 remain baseline pending fresh audit.
## 18 November combined journeys and user-summary projection published
A3 `2c5d04513eb02a9b3771fde5c27ea3e378fc5d92` published/ref-readback verified. Combined browser evidence171e616b integrated213793c1: fresh Release API on combined checklist/analytics source plus unchanged qualified export;4/4 connected discovery/calendar cases,8scans/8screenshots,0violations,0skips/flaky. Prior distinct-case counts overlap; no full/native-language/visual acceptance.
+8
View File
@@ -278,3 +278,11 @@ Next integrity investigation:AttachmentStorage snapshot cleanup ownership (sourc
- [x] **Combined connected backend/browser qualification**.171e616b integrated213793c1, published/refverified;4cases/8scans/8captures pass on fresh combined API with unchanged export. Earlier cases overlap; broader/native-language/visual acceptance remains open.
- [x] **User-list summary SQL projection**.2a212c78 integrated2c5d0451, published/refverified;49to10 selected columns,12 affected ordinary cases+2 actual MariaDB safety fixtures pass,AST/source/native receipts committed. Full Users paging remains open.
## Full design reassessment (new owner direction)
- [ ] Independently audit A3:34routes/57groups,IM01–10 evidence,owner gates,current rendered desktop/tablet/mobile EN/NB light/dark; no final acceptance inferred.
- [ ] Research current public interfaces and create five distinct clickable concepts covering all12 requested screen families and connected journeys. Preserve original prototypes.
- [ ] Compare existing-component redesign,major frontend restructure,and new API-backed frontend; preserve functionality/data/routes.
- [ ] Present consolidated concept/strategy review; explicit owner approval required before replacement implementation.
- [ ] Continue wider authorised roadmap and recovered CV journey while design exploration proceeds.